Home Case Laws Opportunity Restored in GST Penalty Proceedings due to Improper Service of Notices

Opportunity Restored in GST Penalty Proceedings due to Improper Service of Notices

0
189

Case Title: Tvl. Jayam Sai Concrete Works v. State Tax Officer, Investigation Gr-I
Court: High Court of Judicature at Madras
Petition No.: W.P. No. 37384 of 2024 with W.M.P. Nos. 40392 & 40393 of 2024
Date of Judgement: 09.12.2024
Relevant Sections: Section 74 of CGST/TNGST Act, 2017; Rule 142 of CGST Rules, 2017
Category of Dispute: Penalty for Non-generation of E-Way Bills & Procedural Violation


Facts of the Case (with Para References)

  1. The petitioner, a registered dealer in cement products, was subjected to audit inspection on 24.03.2023 for FY 2019-20 (Para 3).

  2. Discrepancies noted included: (i) Non-filing of GSTR-9 & 9C, (ii) Non-payment of RCM on freight, (iii) Non-generation of outward e-way bills (Para 3).

  3. Tax of ₹46,216/- and penalty liability of ₹2.92 crore was intimated through DRC-01A; tax was paid except for defect no.3 (Para 4-5).

  4. Show Cause Notice (SCN) in DRC-01 dated 11.05.2024 imposed only penalty of ₹2.92 crore; petitioner filed reply and made partial payments (Para 4-5).

  5. Three reminders were uploaded on GST portal under “Additional Notices and Orders” tab but not served physically, causing petitioner to miss hearings (Para 6).

  6. Petitioner relied on M/s. K. Balakrishnan, Balu Cables v. AC GST (W.P.(MD) No.11924/2024) to argue improper notice service (Para 7).


Questions in Consideration

  1. Whether uploading notices only on GST portal without proper service amounts to valid service under law? (Para 6).

  2. Whether the penalty order passed without ensuring service and hearing violates principles of natural justice? (Para 6-7).

  3. Whether the impugned assessment order can be set aside and treated as SCN allowing fresh opportunity? (Para 9).


Observations of the Court

  1. Notices uploaded only under “Additional Notices” tab deprived petitioner of effective participation; hence, principles of natural justice were violated (Para 6).

  2. Petitioner had already discharged substantial tax liability and was willing to deposit 25% of disputed dues as condition for fresh hearing (Para 7-8).

  3. Court balanced revenue interest and taxpayer’s right to be heard by setting aside impugned order subject to conditions (Para 9).


Judgement of the Court

  1. Impugned order dated 30.08.2024 was set aside (Para 9).

  2. Respondent directed to verify petitioner’s payment claims and intimate balance within one week (Para 9a-b).

  3. Petitioner to deposit balance of 25% of disputed tax within one week of intimation (Para 9a-b).

  4. On compliance, impugned order to be treated as SCN, allowing petitioner to file objections within four weeks (Para 9c).

  5. If petitioner fails to deposit 25% or file objections in time, impugned assessment will stand revived (Para 9e).


Between Fine Lines (Simple Summary in 5 Lines)

The Madras High Court held that notices only uploaded on the GST portal are not proper service.
The penalty order of nearly ₹2.92 crore was quashed for lack of hearing opportunity.
Court allowed the order to be treated as SCN if the petitioner deposits 25% of disputed tax.
Petitioner is given four weeks to file objections and explain discrepancies.
Failure to comply will revive the earlier penalty order.


Summary of Referred Cases

Case Name Citation Summary Verdict
M/s. K. Balakrishnan, Balu Cables v. AC GST W.P.(MD) No.11924 of 2024, Madras HC, dated 10.06.2024 Court quashed GST demand order where notices were uploaded only on portal without proper service, denying opportunity of hearing. Held that such service violates principles of natural justice; matter remanded for fresh adjudication.

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY