Home Case Laws Order-in-Original Set Aside for Ignoring Assessee’s Reply

Order-in-Original Set Aside for Ignoring Assessee’s Reply

0
370

Case Details

  • Case Title: M/s Perfetti Van Melle India Pvt. Ltd. v. Additional Commissioner (Adj.), CGST Delhi North & Ors.

  • Court: High Court of Delhi at New Delhi

  • Petition Number: W.P.(C) 2178/2025 & CM APPL. 10285/2025

  • Date of Judgement: 16th April, 2025

  • Category of Dispute: Classification of Goods & Rate of GST

  • Relevant Sections: Section 9, Section 169 CGST Act, 2017; Principles of Natural Justice

  • Impugned Order: Order-in-Original No. 35/ADC/D.N./BHAVAN MEENA/2024 dated 06.01.2025 and Form GST DRC-07 dated 25.01.2025


Facts of the Case (Paras 2–7)

  • The Petitioner challenged an Order-in-Original dated 06.01.2025, followed by DRC-07, demanding ₹10.86 crores GST alleging short payment (Para 2–4).

  • Issue was classification of petitioner’s products – whether taxable at 12% or 18% (Para 3).

  • Petitioner filed a detailed reply on 02.09.2024 (uploaded on portal, emailed, and served physically on 03.09.2024) (Para 5–6).

  • However, the adjudicating authority wrongly recorded that no reply was filed, and passed an ex-parte order holding allegations as admitted (Para 7).


Question(s) in Consideration (Para 3, 8, 12)

  1. Whether the adjudicating authority erred in ignoring the reply duly filed by the Petitioner?

  2. Whether principles of natural justice were violated by passing the order ex-parte?

  3. Whether such an order, though appealable, can be sustained when the reply itself was disregarded?


Observations of the Court (Paras 8, 13–17)

  • A demand exceeding ₹10 crores was confirmed without considering petitioner’s reply, which was filed within time (Para 8).

  • The Order-in-Original incorrectly recorded “no reply received”, rendering it unsustainable (Para 13).

  • The Court held that merely providing an appellate remedy does not cure violation of natural justice (Para 12–14).

  • The matter requires fresh adjudication after proper hearing (Para 15–16).


Judgement of the Court (Paras 14–21)

  • The impugned Order-in-Original dated 06.01.2025 was set aside (Para 14).

  • Case remanded to the adjudicating authority for fresh hearing (Para 15).

  • Department directed to give three dates of personal hearing and ensure notices are uploaded on portal, emailed, and sent via SMS to designated officers (Para 16–17).

  • Court clarified it has not examined merits of classification issue (Para 20).

  • All rights and remedies of the parties remain open (Para 21).


Between Fine Lines (Simple Summary)

  • Perfetti Van Melle challenged a ₹10.86 crore GST demand.

  • The adjudicating authority wrongly noted that no reply was filed, though it was duly submitted.

  • The High Court held this was a violation of natural justice.

  • The demand order was set aside and the matter remanded for reconsideration.

  • Court insisted on proper communication of hearings and fresh adjudication.


Summary of Referred Cases

Case Name Citation Summary Verdict
(Not specifically cited in judgment; petitioner mentioned “two other jurisdictions” with favourable decisions to be placed before adjudicating authority) – – –

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY