Home Case Laws Order quashed since specific request for personal hearing was made in reply...

Order quashed since specific request for personal hearing was made in reply to the SCN.

0
296

Case Title: Raj Kumar Singh v. Assistant Commissioner

Court: High Court of Calcutta

Petition No.: WPA 9561 of 2022

Date of Judgement: June 14, 2022

Category of Dispute: Violation of Principles of Natural Justice

Relevant Section: Section 75(4) of the CGST Act, 2017 (opportunity of hearing)

 

Facts of the Case [¶ 2–3]

  1. The petitioner challenged an adjudication order dated 9th May 2021 on the grounds of violation of natural justice.
  2. In response to the Show Cause Notice (SCN) dated 13th April 2021, the petitioner specifically requested a personal hearing, which was neither granted nor rejected.
  3. The adjudication order merely records that the reply was considered, but there is no mention of any action on the personal hearing request.

 

Questions in Consideration [¶ 2]

  • Whether the adjudication order passed without granting or considering the request for personal hearing is valid under the CGST Act and consistent with the principles of natural justice?

Observations of the Court [¶ 3–4]

  1. The Court noted that the adjudicating authority failed to consider or reject the petitioner’s request for a personal hearing.
  2. The Additional Government Pleader could not dispute this omission.
  3. The Court emphasized that non-consideration of a specific request for personal hearing constitutes a breach of the principle of natural justice as mandated under Section 75(4) of the CGST Act

 

Judgement of the Court [¶ 5–6]

  • The impugned adjudication order dated 9th May 2021 was set aside.
  • The case was remanded to the Adjudicating Authority with a direction to provide a proper opportunity of hearing (either in person or through an authorized representative) to the petitioner and to pass a fresh order within eight weeks of receipt of the High Court’s order.

Between Fine Lines

  • If a taxpayer specifically requests a personal hearing in response to an SCN, authorities must either grant or formally reject such a request.
  • Failure to address a personal hearing request violates Section 75(4) of the CGST Act and natural justice.
  • The Court will set aside adjudication orders passed in such violation.
  • Remand orders ensure the petitioner’s right to be heard is honored.
  • The authorities must now complete a fresh adjudication after granting a fair hearing.

 

Summary of Referred Cases

(No external cases were referred to in the judgment.)

Takeaway

“Silence is Not Compliance: Denial of Hearing without Rejection Violates Natural Justice”

LEAVE A REPLY