Case Title: Ramasamy Singaravelan (deceased) Rep. by Legal Heir S. Sumathi vs. Deputy State Tax Officer
Court: Madras High Court
Petition Numbers: W.P. Nos. 28496 & 28499 of 2024 (with W.M.P. Nos. 31070–31073 of 2024)
Date of Judgement: 25.09.2024
Category of Dispute: Natural Justice / Validity of Orders
Relevant Sections: Section 75 CGST/TNGST Act, 2017 (procedure for determination of tax), Rule 142 CGST Rules (issuance of DRC-01, DRC-07)
Facts of the Case
-
The petitioner’s husband, Ramasamy Singaravelan, proprietor of Sri Bhagavathi Amman Electricals, died on 07.05.2022. Despite this, the department continued issuing notices and passed orders in his name for FY 2017–18 (order dated 26.12.2023) and FY 2022–23 (order dated 28.03.2024) [Para 3].
-
The legal heir, S. Sumathi (wife of deceased), came to know of the orders only upon a recovery intimation through a phone call from the respondent [Para 3].
-
The impugned orders were passed without notice to legal heirs and were therefore challenged as void ab initio for being issued against a dead person [Para 3.1].
Questions in Consideration
-
Whether assessment and recovery orders passed in the name of a deceased assessee are valid? [Para 6].
-
Whether principles of natural justice stand violated when no opportunity of representation is given to the legal heir? [Para 7].
Observations of the Court
-
Notices were issued against a person who had already died, and the department was unaware of the death. Passing assessment orders in the name of a deceased is impermissible [Para 6].
-
The orders were ex parte and amounted to violation of natural justice, as legal heirs were not given any notice or opportunity to contest [Para 7].
-
Such orders are void ab initio and cannot be sustained in law [Para 7].
Judgement of the Court
-
The impugned orders dated 26.12.2023 and 28.03.2024 along with consequential recovery orders dated 26.12.2023 and 30.03.2024 were set aside [Para 8(i)].
-
The matter was remitted to the department for fresh consideration [Para 8(ii)].
-
The petitioner (legal heir) was directed to file replies to earlier DRC-01 notices within four weeks [Para 8(iii)].
-
The respondent was directed to issue a 14-day hearing notice and thereafter pass orders afresh in accordance with law [Para 8(iv)].
Between Fine Lines
-
Orders passed against a deceased assessee are null and void.
-
Recovery cannot be initiated without notice to legal heirs.
-
Natural justice requires that legal heirs must be given an opportunity to contest.
-
Court has remitted the case for fresh adjudication with directions for proper hearing.
-
Departments must verify assessee status before initiating proceedings.
Summary of Referred Cases
(No specific earlier cases were cited in the judgment. The Court relied solely on principles of natural justice and legal impossibility of proceeding against a dead person.)
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




