Home Case Laws Penalty Under GST Can Be Adjudicated Without Criminal Trial: Patanjali’s Plea Dismissed

Penalty Under GST Can Be Adjudicated Without Criminal Trial: Patanjali’s Plea Dismissed

0
477

Case Summary

Case Title: M/s Patanjali Ayurved Ltd. v. Union of India and Others
Court Name: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
Petition Number: WRIT-TAX NO. 1603 OF 2024
Category of Dispute: Penalty – Interpretation of Section 122 CGST Act
Date of Judgement: 29 May 2025
Relevant Sections: Sections 122, 74, 132, 134, 83 of CGST Act, Rule 142 of CGST Rules
Coram: Hon’ble Shekhar B. Saraf, J. and Hon’ble Vipin Chandra Dixit, J.


Facts of the Case [¶2–10]

  1. M/s Patanjali Ayurved Ltd., having manufacturing units in Uttarakhand, Haryana, and Maharashtra, received a show cause notice (SCN) dated 19.04.2024 from DGGI proposing a penalty of ₹273.51 crore under Sections 122(1)(ii) and (vii) of CGST Act for allegedly issuing fake invoices and availing ineligible ITC without supply of goods [¶2(e)].

  2. The SCN was issued under both Sections 74 and 122 CGST Act, but the petitioner only challenged the penalty under Section 122, terming it exorbitant and invalid [¶2(f)].

  3. During adjudication, proceedings under Section 74 were dropped by the authority on 10.01.2025, after it found that goods were received and outward supplies were genuine, with no evidence of non-existent suppliers or stock discrepancies [¶2(g), ¶2(h), ¶2(i)].


Question(s) in Consideration [¶5, ¶40]

  1. Whether penalty under Section 122 of CGST Act must be adjudicated only by criminal courts (through trial) and not by GST adjudicating authorities?

  2. Whether dropping of proceedings under Section 74 against the main taxable person would automatically nullify proceedings under Section 122?


Observation of the Court [¶15–¶52]

  1. The court elaborated on the definition of “offence” and “penalty” and held that these terms do not always imply criminal prosecution. Penalty under GST is a civil obligation, not a criminal punishment, unless expressly specified [¶15–¶20].

  2. Section 122 imposes civil penalties for contraventions such as fake invoicing, while Section 132 deals with criminal punishment, requiring prior sanction from the Commissioner and adjudication by Magistrate [¶45–¶47].

  3. Section 74 deals with determination of tax and penalty due to fraud or suppression. If such proceedings are dropped against the main person, it may lead to deemed conclusion of Section 122 only for co-noticees, not necessarily the main person himself [¶52].

  4. The court interpreted Rule 142 and Section 83 to clarify that adjudicating authorities (proper officers) are empowered to levy penalty under Section 122 [¶50].

  5. The petitioner’s argument that Section 122 is criminal in nature because of use of words like “offence”, “aiding and abetting”, etc., was rejected. The court held these are merely indicative of gravity but do not convert the penalty into a criminal liability [¶40–¶48].


Judgment of the Court [¶53–¶55]

  • Section 122 CGST Act pertains to civil liability and penalty, and adjudicating officers are competent to adjudicate it.

  • Dropping of proceedings under Section 74 does not automatically nullify Section 122 penalty proceedings.

  • Writ petition dismissed. Authorities may proceed with adjudication under Section 122 as per the issued SCN.


Between Fine Lines

  • The court clarified that not all GST penalties amount to criminal liability.

  • Penalty under Section 122 can be imposed by GST officers and need not be prosecuted through courts.

  • Offences under Section 132 alone attract criminal trials and not those under Section 122.

  • Closure of proceedings under Section 74 does not extinguish penalty under Section 122.

  • GST law allows coexisting civil and criminal penalties, depending on the nature and gravity of the contravention.


Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
Shiv Dutt Rai Fateh Chand v. Union of India (1983) 3 SCC 529 Discussed penalty as civil obligation in tax laws Affirmed civil nature of tax penalties
Gujarat Travancore Agency v. CIT (1989) 3 SCC 52 Distinguished between civil penalty and criminal punishment Penalty under tax law is civil
MCTM Corporation Pvt. Ltd. v. Directorate of Enforcement (1996) 2 SCC 471 Held penalty for breach of civil duty need not require mens rea Affirmed civil liability
Standard Chartered Bank v. Directorate of Enforcement (2006) 4 SCC 278 Defined “offence” as any act punishable by law, not necessarily criminal Broadened meaning of “offence”
SEBI v. Cabot International Capital Corp. 2004 SCC OnLine Bom 180 Distinguished mens rea requirement in civil vs criminal penalties Affirmed adjudicatory penalty as civil
State of Tamil Nadu v. K. Shyam Sunder (2011) 8 SCC 737 Highlighted legislative intent in tax statutes Applied harmonious construction

LEAVE A REPLY