Home Case Laws Penalty under Section 125 set aside as late fee under Section 47...

Penalty under Section 125 set aside as late fee under Section 47 suffices for delayed GST return filing

0
382
Case Reference:

Tvl. Jainsons Castors & Industrial Products vs. Assistant Commissioner (ST), Ekkatuthangal Assessment Circle
Court: Madras High Court
Petition No.: W.P. No. 36614 of 2024 and W.M.P. No. 39493 of 2024
Date of Judgment: 04.02.2025
Relevant Sections: Sections 44, 47, 73, and 125 of the Tamil Nadu GST Act, 2017
Category: Penalty – Delay in filing of Annual Return

Facts (Para 2–4):

The petitioner, Tvl. Jainsons Castors & Industrial Products, challenged the assessment order issued in Form GST DRC-07 dated 24.07.2024 under Section 73 of the TNGST Act. The petitioner contended that although they filed their annual return belatedly, no notice was served under Section 46 before initiating proceedings. They argued that as per Section 47(2), only a late fee can be imposed for delayed filing of the return and that invoking Section 73 (determination of tax) and Section 125 (general penalty) was legally unsustainable.

The respondent contended that since the petitioner failed to file the annual return under Section 44, proceedings were rightly initiated under Sections 47 and 73, and the demand was proper.


Questions before the Court:

Whether the imposition of penalty under Section 125, in addition to the late fee under Section 47, is valid when the only default was delay in filing the annual return.


Observations (Para 6–7):

The Court observed that Section 47(2) specifically deals with the imposition of a late fee for delay in filing the annual return. The provision is self-contained and exclusive, prescribing a maximum fee based on turnover. Therefore, for such default, Section 73 (determination of tax) is not attracted.

Further, Section 125—the general penalty clause—applies only when no separate penalty is provided elsewhere in the Act. Since Section 47 provides for a late fee mechanism, invoking Section 125 to levy an additional penalty of ₹50,000 (₹25,000 under CGST and SGST each) was legally untenable.


Judgment (Para 8):

The Court held that the imposition of the general penalty under Section 125 was erroneous and set aside the same. However, the late fee under Section 47 was found to be valid and sustained.

The writ petition was thus partly allowed, confirming the levy of late fee but quashing the additional penalty.


Summary of Cases Referred

Case Citation/Section Verdict
Present Case W.P. No. 36614 of 2024 (Madras HC) Penalty under Section 125 quashed; late fee under Section 47 upheld.

Between Fine Lines (Trade Perspective):

This judgment clarifies that for delay in filing of annual returns, authorities can levy only the statutory late fee under Section 47(2) and cannot invoke Section 125 for additional penalty. It reinforces the principle that specific provisions override general penalty clauses, thereby preventing arbitrary penalization of taxpayers for procedural delays.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY