Home Case Laws Penalty under Section 129 quashed as mere human error in e-way bill...

Penalty under Section 129 quashed as mere human error in e-way bill without intention to evade tax cannot justify detention and levy

0
362

Case Details

  • Case Title: M/s Vishnu Singh v. State of U.P. and 2 Others

  • Court: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad

  • Petition No.: Writ Tax No. 599 of 2024

  • Judgment Date: 20.02.2025

  • Neutral Citation: 2025:AHC:24812

  • Hon’ble Judge: Justice Piyush Agrawal

  • Relevant Section: Section 129(3) of the CGST Act, Rule 138 of CGST Rules

  • Category of Dispute: GST detention and penalty on account of e-way bill error

Facts (Paras 2–4, 8)

The petitioner, a proprietorship firm engaged in civil works, purchased 24.948 kgs of Durapave bitumen from IOCL, Mathura and transported it to Mirzapur. While generating the e-way bill on 29.08.2023, due to a human error, the SAP document number was mentioned instead of the tax invoice number. The vehicle was intercepted at Etawah on 30.08.2023. Though all other documents were valid and consistent, authorities detained the goods, alleging discrepancy. Proceedings under Section 129(3) were initiated, resulting in penalty orders dated 04.09.2023 (by respondent no. 3) and confirmation in appeal on 20.03.2024 (by respondent no. 2).


Questions before the Court (Paras 2, 4, 9)

  1. Whether a mere technical mistake in mentioning SAP document number instead of invoice number in e-way bill amounts to a violation justifying penalty under Section 129?

  2. Whether absence of a finding regarding intention to evade tax invalidates penalty proceedings under GST law?


Observations (Paras 8–10)

  • The Court noted that except the invoice number mismatch, no discrepancy existed regarding goods’ quality, quantity, or details.

  • The error was a genuine human error during e-way bill generation.

  • Importantly, no finding of intent to evade tax was recorded by the authorities, which is essential for imposing penalty under Section 129.

  • Relying on earlier rulings in M/s Zhuzoor Infratech Pvt. Ltd. (Writ Tax No. 830/2024, decided 14.02.2025) and M/s Sun Flag Iron and Steel Co. Ltd. v. State of U.P. (2023:AHC:215906), the Court reiterated that the purpose of the e-way bill is only to track movement of goods so transactions are not lost to assessment. Mere technical defects do not justify harsh penal action.


Judgement (Paras 11–12)

The High Court held that penalty proceedings initiated against the petitioner were unjustified. Since there was no intent to evade tax and only a clerical error existed, the orders dated 04.09.2023 and 20.03.2024 under Section 129(3) were quashed. The writ petition was allowed.


Table of Cases Referred

Case Court Issue Verdict
M/s Zhuzoor Infratech Pvt. Ltd. v. Addl. Commissioner (Writ Tax 830/2024, 14.02.2025) Allahabad HC E-way bill validity & cancellation Held that purpose of e-way bill is only to track movement; no penalty if not cancelled and transaction is genuine
M/s Sun Flag Iron & Steel Co. Ltd. v. State of U.P. (2023:AHC:215906) Allahabad HC Expired e-way bill and seizure Held that once e-way bill generated and not cancelled, genuineness of movement cannot be questioned; penalty on technical lapse unsustainable

Between Fine Lines

For businesses, this ruling reinforces that minor clerical errors in e-way bills without intent to evade tax cannot be the basis for detention and penalty under Section 129. Authorities must establish tax evasion intent, otherwise seizure orders are liable to be struck down. Firms must however ensure timely rectification of e-way bills to avoid unnecessary litigation.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY