Home Case Laws Penalty under Section 74 of the CGST Act quashed as employee secondment...

Penalty under Section 74 of the CGST Act quashed as employee secondment tax dispute was interpretational, not fraudulent

0
238

Case: M/s BSH Household Appliances Manufacturing Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Tax & Anr.,
Court: High Court of Karnataka, Bengaluru
Petition No.: Writ Petition No. 11574 of 2025 (T-RES)
Date of Judgment: 16 July 2025
Category: Demand and Penalty under Section 74 of CGST Act – Interpretation Dispute on Taxability of Secondment Services
Relevant Sections: Sections 74, 128A of the CGST Act, 2017


Facts (Paras 2–9)

M/s BSH Household Appliances Manufacturing Pvt. Ltd., engaged in manufacturing home appliances across Karnataka, Maharashtra, and Tamil Nadu, had expatriate employees seconded from its German parent company under a Delegation Agreement dated 01.07.2011. These expatriates were under the petitioner’s control, drawing salaries partly in India and partly in Germany.

Following the Supreme Court ruling in C.C., C.E. & S.T., Bangalore v. Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd., 2022 (5) TMI 967 (SC), which held such secondment arrangements taxable as “Manpower Supply Services,” the petitioner voluntarily paid IGST for July 2017–June 2022 across all three states in July–August 2022 via GSTR-3B and DRC-03.

Nevertheless, separate show cause notices were issued by each jurisdiction alleging delayed tax payment and proposing interest and penalty under Section 74 of the CGST Act. The petitioner contended that liability arose only after the Supreme Court decision and thus interest and penalty were unwarranted. The adjudicating authority, however, rejected this and imposed penalty.


Questions before the Court (Para 13)

Whether an assessee, whose interpretation of tax liability was later reversed by the Supreme Court, is liable for interest and penalty under Section 74 of the CGST Act when the dispute was purely interpretational and not due to fraud, suppression, or wilful misstatement.


Observations (Paras 14–15)

The Court noted that the petitioner had fully disclosed secondment arrangements in its books and before tax authorities. The issue was solely interpretational — initially resolved in favor of assessees by tribunals until reversed by the Apex Court. Thus, the basic conditions under Section 74 — fraud, wilful misstatement, or suppression — were not met.

The Court clarified that while penalty could not be levied, interest on delayed tax payment would still be payable, as the service had been consumed earlier. The quantum of such interest was to be determined factually by the department.


Judgment (Para 16)

  • The writ petition was partly allowed.

  • The impugned Order-in-Original No. 88/2024-25 (GST-JC) dated 02.02.2025 was set aside.

  • The matter was remitted to the adjudicating authority for fresh consideration consistent with Court’s findings.

  • The petitioner was held eligible for relief under Section 128A (Amnesty Scheme) if applicable.


Summary of Cases Referred

Case Citation Principle Verdict Summary
C.C., C.E. & S.T., Bangalore v. Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd. 2022 (5) TMI 967 (SC) Secondment of foreign employees constitutes “manpower supply service”; taxable under service tax/GST. Supreme Court upheld taxability, overturning Tribunal rulings favoring assessee.

Between Fine Lines

The judgment reinforces that interpretational disputes cannot trigger penalties under Section 74 of the CGST Act unless accompanied by deliberate evasion or misstatement. Businesses that acted bona fide before clarity from the Apex Court may be protected from penal consequences but must still discharge applicable interest on delayed tax payments.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY