Home Case Laws Penalty upheld under Section 74 as non-filing of returns and non-payment of...

Penalty upheld under Section 74 as non-filing of returns and non-payment of GST were treated as wilful suppression of facts

0
406

Case: M/s Sriba Nirman Company v. The Commissioner (Appeals), Guntur & Others
Court: High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Amaravati
Petition No.: W.P. No. 25826 of 2023
Date of Judgment: 29 January 2025
Category: Penalty under Section 74 – Suppression / Wilful Misstatement
Relevant Sections: Sections 37, 39, 44, 50, 73, 74, 122 & 125 of the CGST Act 2017; Rule 61 of the CGST Rules 2017

Facts (Paras 2–3)

The petitioner, a partnership works contractor registered under GST, executed EPC contracts as a sub-contractor for M/s Vijay Nirman Company Ltd. during FY 2017-18. It raised invoices of ₹ 20.92 crore (GST ₹ 3.19 crore) in March 2018 but failed to file GSTR-3B returns due to cash-flow issues, as payments from the main contractor were insufficient.

A search was conducted by DGGI Visakhapatnam on 31 July 2018, after which the petitioner voluntarily paid the full tax of ₹ 3.36 crore and filed all pending returns by 29 Sept 2018. Two years later, DGGI issued show-cause notices in Aug–Sept 2020 alleging wilful suppression and demanding penalty equal to tax under Section 74(1). The Adjudicating Authority confirmed the demand, and the Appellate Authority upheld the penalty.


Questions before the Court (Para 4)

  1. Whether Section 74 could be invoked despite the entire tax having been paid before issuance of the SCN.

  2. Whether delayed payment without intent could be construed as wilful suppression or fraud.

  3. Whether liability could arise only after the annual return due date under Section 44.


Observations (Paras 6–30)

The Court elaborated the statutory scheme:

  • Sections 37–39 mandate monthly GSTR-3B returns with tax payment by the 20th of the following month; non-filing constitutes statutory contravention.

  • Section 73 applies to ordinary defaults; Section 74 applies to fraud, wilful misstatement, or suppression to evade tax.

  • “Suppression” (Explanation 2 to Section 74) means non-declaration of required information; however, it must be wilful to invoke Section 74.

Relying on Adecco Flexione (2012), Tirupathi Fuels (2017) and Uniworth Textiles (2013 SC), the Court acknowledged that mere delay is not fraud but emphasized that mens rea can be inferred from conduct.

The CBIC Instruction No. 05/2023 dated 13 Dec 2023 was cited, clarifying that Section 74 should apply only where evidence of intent to evade exists. Nonetheless, the Bench found that the petitioner had received some payments but failed to remit tax, showing deliberate suppression.

The plea that annual return due date (7 Feb 2020) extended the filing timeline was rejected since monthly returns under Sections 37–39 are independent obligations.


Judgment (Paras 30–31)

The Court held that:

  • The petitioner’s non-filing of monthly returns and non-payment of GST amounted to wilful suppression under Section 74(1).

  • The argument that the entire tax was paid before SCN did not help since interest and 15% penalty under Section 74(5) were not paid before notice.

  • Therefore, invocation of Section 74 and the consequential penalties were valid.

Writ petition dismissed; penalty upheld.


Table – Cases Referred

Case Court & Citation Ratio / Verdict
CCE v. Adecco Flexione Workforce Solutions Ltd. (2012) 26 STR 3 (Kar) Payment of tax with interest before SCN precludes penalty under s.73(3).
CCE v. Tirupathi Fuels Pvt. Ltd. (2017) 7 GSTL 142 (AP) No penalty if tax & interest are paid before notice; differs from GST law.
Uniworth Textiles Ltd. v. CCE (2013) 288 ELT 161 (SC) Mere non-payment ≠ suppression; intent to evade must be shown.

Between Fine Lines (Trade Takeaway)

Even if GST is later paid voluntarily, failure to file monthly returns and pay tax on time can be deemed wilful suppression if receipts existed. Section 74 penalty equal to tax may apply unless the taxpayer also pays interest and 15% penalty before SCN under Section 74(5). Businesses must ensure timely GSTR-3B filing regardless of cash-flow delays from clients.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY