Case Title: Macmet Engineering Ltd. v. Commissioner of Commercial Taxes
Court: High Court of Madras
Petition No.: W.P.(MD) Nos. 19395 to 19399 of 2022
Date of Judgment: September 1, 2022
Relevant Sections: Section 68(3), Section 129(1)(b) of CGST Act, Section 20 of IGST Act, Rule 138A of CGST Rules, Section 126(1) of CGST Act
Category of Dispute: E-Way Bill Compliance & Detention of Goods under “Bill to – Ship to” Model
Facts of the Case [¶2–5, 8–12]
- Macmet Engineering Ltd., a Kolkata-based GST-registered entity, was awarded a back-to-back EPC contract by ITD Cementation India Ltd., the main contractor to TANGEDCO for a thermal power project.
- Macmet procured steel cord pipe conveyor belts from Phoenix Conveyor Belt India Pvt. Ltd. to be delivered directly to TANGEDCO’s site in Tamil Nadu.
- The transaction followed the “Bill to – Ship to” model, where Phoenix billed Macmet, and goods were shipped to ITD/TANGEDCO site.
- Five consignments in transit were detained on 2-8-2022 by GST roving squads on the ground that the e-way bills/invoices did not mention the actual recipient (ITD Cementation), but instead erroneously listed Macmet as consignee.
- The department issued SCNs citing violation of e-way bill requirements and imposed penalty under Section 129(1)(b) of CGST Act.
Questions in Consideration [¶6, 15, 23]
- Whether minor clerical error in “consignee name” on e-way bills invalidates a transaction structured under a legitimate “Bill to – Ship to” model?
- Whether the Roving Squad is competent to impose penalties without referring the matter to the jurisdictional assessing officer?
- Whether there was tax evasion or revenue loss due to the invoice discrepancy?
Observations of the Court [¶22–33]
- The petitioner acted under a valid sub-contract and had duly issued PO to Phoenix with correct “Ship to” address.
- The only mistake was Phoenix incorrectly naming Macmet instead of ITD as consignee; however, the correct delivery location (TANGEDCO site) was clearly mentioned.
- IGST was duly charged and invoices were uploaded on GSTN; 14 similar consignments had already reached the destination without issue.
- The court held that such documentation error was rectifiable under Section 126(1) of CGST Act and did not warrant harsh action.
- Circular No. 10/2019 mandates that valuation/classification-related matters be decided by the jurisdictional officer, not the Roving Squad.
- Relying on precedents (e.g., Jeyyam Global Foods Pvt. Ltd., NVK Mohammed Sulthan, K.P. Sugandh Ltd.), the court concluded that in bona fide cases, detention is unjustified.
Judgment of the Court [¶33–34]
- The High Court quashed the detention orders.
- Directed the roving squad to forward all records to the jurisdictional assessing officer.
- Petitioner to execute a bond covering the tax and penalty amount as safeguard.
- The jurisdictional officer shall decide the matter on its own merits after hearing the petitioner.
- No costs imposed.
Between Fine Lines
- Clerical errors in GST documentation that do not affect tax liability or supply chain integrity are not grounds for detention.
- Triangular transactions must comply with e-way bill norms, but minor discrepancies should be treated under Section 126 CGST.
- Roving squads cannot adjudicate classification/valuation issues—jurisdiction lies with assessing officers.
- IGST charged properly with no evasion negates justification for penalty.
- Detention without loss of revenue or fraudulent intent is unwarranted.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict/Principle |
| Jeyyam Global Foods Pvt. Ltd. v. UOI | 2019 (21) GSTL 465 (Mad.) | Vehicle detention for procedural lapse despite valid transaction challenged. | Only jurisdictional officer can decide such disputes, not the Roving Squad. |
| NVK Mohammed Sulthan Rawther and Sons v. UOI | 2019 (20) GSTL 708 (Ker.) | Dispute over classification; matter referred to proper authority. | Roving squad not competent to decide classification. |
| K.P. Sugandh Ltd. v. State of Chhattisgarh | 2020 (38) GSTL 317 (Chhattisgarh) | Clerical mistakes in documents held non-fraudulent and curable. | Technical breaches without tax loss shouldn’t attract harsh penalties. |
| Shri Venkateshvara Logistics v. Asst. Commr. of C.T. | 2020 (41) GSTL 145 (Kar.) | Valid documentation existed for perishable goods. | Goods should not be detained when accompanied by lawful invoices and details. |




