Home Case Laws Power of Roving Squad Officials to issue show cause notice and pass...

Power of Roving Squad Officials to issue show cause notice and pass order of detention.

0
282

Case Title: Macmet Engineering Ltd. v. Commissioner of Commercial Taxes

Court: High Court of Madras

Petition No.: W.P.(MD) Nos. 19395 to 19399 of 2022

Date of Judgment: September 1, 2022

Relevant Sections: Section 68(3), Section 129(1)(b) of CGST Act, Section 20 of IGST Act, Rule 138A of CGST Rules, Section 126(1) of CGST Act

Category of Dispute: E-Way Bill Compliance & Detention of Goods under “Bill to – Ship to” Model

 

Facts of the Case [¶2–5, 8–12]

  • Macmet Engineering Ltd., a Kolkata-based GST-registered entity, was awarded a back-to-back EPC contract by ITD Cementation India Ltd., the main contractor to TANGEDCO for a thermal power project.
  • Macmet procured steel cord pipe conveyor belts from Phoenix Conveyor Belt India Pvt. Ltd. to be delivered directly to TANGEDCO’s site in Tamil Nadu.
  • The transaction followed the “Bill to – Ship to” model, where Phoenix billed Macmet, and goods were shipped to ITD/TANGEDCO site.
  • Five consignments in transit were detained on 2-8-2022 by GST roving squads on the ground that the e-way bills/invoices did not mention the actual recipient (ITD Cementation), but instead erroneously listed Macmet as consignee.
  • The department issued SCNs citing violation of e-way bill requirements and imposed penalty under Section 129(1)(b) of CGST Act.

 

Questions in Consideration [¶6, 15, 23]

  1. Whether minor clerical error in “consignee name” on e-way bills invalidates a transaction structured under a legitimate “Bill to – Ship to” model?
  2. Whether the Roving Squad is competent to impose penalties without referring the matter to the jurisdictional assessing officer?
  3. Whether there was tax evasion or revenue loss due to the invoice discrepancy?

 

Observations of the Court [¶22–33]

  • The petitioner acted under a valid sub-contract and had duly issued PO to Phoenix with correct “Ship to” address.
  • The only mistake was Phoenix incorrectly naming Macmet instead of ITD as consignee; however, the correct delivery location (TANGEDCO site) was clearly mentioned.
  • IGST was duly charged and invoices were uploaded on GSTN; 14 similar consignments had already reached the destination without issue.
  • The court held that such documentation error was rectifiable under Section 126(1) of CGST Act and did not warrant harsh action.
  • Circular No. 10/2019 mandates that valuation/classification-related matters be decided by the jurisdictional officer, not the Roving Squad.
  • Relying on precedents (e.g., Jeyyam Global Foods Pvt. Ltd., NVK Mohammed Sulthan, K.P. Sugandh Ltd.), the court concluded that in bona fide cases, detention is unjustified.

 

Judgment of the Court [¶33–34]

  • The High Court quashed the detention orders.
  • Directed the roving squad to forward all records to the jurisdictional assessing officer.
  • Petitioner to execute a bond covering the tax and penalty amount as safeguard.
  • The jurisdictional officer shall decide the matter on its own merits after hearing the petitioner.
  • No costs imposed.

 

Between Fine Lines

  • Clerical errors in GST documentation that do not affect tax liability or supply chain integrity are not grounds for detention.
  • Triangular transactions must comply with e-way bill norms, but minor discrepancies should be treated under Section 126 CGST.
  • Roving squads cannot adjudicate classification/valuation issues—jurisdiction lies with assessing officers.
  • IGST charged properly with no evasion negates justification for penalty.
  • Detention without loss of revenue or fraudulent intent is unwarranted.

 

Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict/Principle
Jeyyam Global Foods Pvt. Ltd. v. UOI 2019 (21) GSTL 465 (Mad.) Vehicle detention for procedural lapse despite valid transaction challenged. Only jurisdictional officer can decide such disputes, not the Roving Squad.
NVK Mohammed Sulthan Rawther and Sons v. UOI 2019 (20) GSTL 708 (Ker.) Dispute over classification; matter referred to proper authority. Roving squad not competent to decide classification.
K.P. Sugandh Ltd. v. State of Chhattisgarh 2020 (38) GSTL 317 (Chhattisgarh) Clerical mistakes in documents held non-fraudulent and curable. Technical breaches without tax loss shouldn’t attract harsh penalties.
Shri Venkateshvara Logistics v. Asst. Commr. of C.T. 2020 (41) GSTL 145 (Kar.) Valid documentation existed for perishable goods. Goods should not be detained when accompanied by lawful invoices and details.

 

LEAVE A REPLY