Case Title: Amazonite Steel (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India
Court: High Court of Calcutta
Petition Number: W.P. Nos. 18429, 18431, 18433, 21272 to 21274 of 2019
Date of Judgment: 4 March 2020
Relevant Section: Section 83 of the CGST Act, 2017
Category of Dispute: Provisional Attachment
Facts of the Case (Paras 2 to 3)
- The petitioners, Amazonite Steel Pvt. Ltd. and its director, were subjected to a provisional attachment of their bank account by the DGGI Kolkata under Section 83 CGST Act vide order dated 5 June 2018. (Para 2(c))
- The order was not revoked despite expiry of the one-year statutory period under Section 83(2). Representations by the petitioner to de-freeze the account were ignored. (Paras 2(e)–2(h))
- A new attachment order was passed on 31 October 2019, without serving it personally on the petitioner. The petitioners then filed fresh writ petitions challenging the same. (Para 2(k))
Questions in Consideration
- Whether the Principal Additional Director General and Additional Director General of DGGI are competent to pass orders under Section 83? (Para 3, Issue A)
- Whether a provisional attachment order remains valid after expiry of one year? (Para 3, Issue B)
- Whether fresh or multiple orders of provisional attachment under Section 83 are legally permissible? (Para 3, Issue C)
Observations of the Court
Issue A – Competency to Pass Orders (Paras 4–7):
The Court upheld that officers holding the rank of Principal Additional Director General and Additional Director General of DGGI fall within the meaning of “Commissioner” under Section 2(24) read with Section 3(c) and 3(d) CGST Act. They are thus empowered to issue orders under Section 83. (Para 7)
Issue B – Expiry of Provisional Attachment (Paras 8–11):
The Court strongly criticized the revenue for not withdrawing the attachment after one year (5 June 2019) as required under Section 83(2), calling it “reprehensible” and violative of Article 19(1)(g) and 300A of the Constitution. The Court awarded ₹5 lakhs in costs to each petitioner. (Paras 11)
Issue C – Legality of Fresh Orders (Paras 28–36):
The Court held that Section 83(2) does not bar fresh provisional attachment orders post expiry of the initial one-year term. However, any fresh order must be based on fresh review and not merely an extension disguised as a new order. (Paras 31–34)
Judgment of the Court
- The Court ruled in favour of the Revenue on Issue A and C.
- The Court ruled in favour of the Petitioners on Issue B and directed the Revenue to pay ₹5 lakhs as costs to each petitioner company. (Para 37)
- All writ petitions were disposed of. (Para 40)
Between Fine Lines
- Only Commissioners and equivalent officers (including ADG and PADG) can pass Section 83 orders.
- Provisional attachment automatically lapses after 1 year unless a new valid order is issued.
- Fresh provisional attachments can be issued if properly justified, but not as mechanical extensions.
- Failure to lift expired attachments without notice is a constitutional violation.
- ₹15 lakhs total cost was imposed on Revenue for unlawful inaction.
📚 Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| Valerius Industries v. Union of India | [2019] 3 G.S.T.L. 15 (Guj.) | Section 83 attachment must be based on credible material and used sparingly | Cited to support strict interpretation |
| Shrimati Priti v. State of Gujarat | 2011 SCC Online Guj 1869 | Fresh attachment permissible under analogous VAT law | Favoured Revenue |
| Kaithal Timber Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Gujarat | Special Civil App. No. 14039 of 2017 | Fresh order permissible if reassessed | Favoured Revenue |
| VLS Finance Ltd. v. ACIT | [2012] SCC Online Del 1363 | Time-bound nature of attachment under Income-tax Act | Distinction drawn |
| Shrimati Majjo v. ACIT | [1991] 187 ITR 642 | Extension beyond statutory period not permitted | Not applicable to fresh orders |
| Pranit Hem Desai v. ADG | SCA No. 9392 of 2019 (Guj.) | Emphasized caution in using Section 83 | Not on point for fresh orders |
Takeaway:
“Expiry is not immunity – Fresh attachment permitted but with caution”




