Case: Kesari Nandan Mobile v. Office of Assistant Commissioner of State Tax (2), Enforcement, Division 5
Court: High Court of Gujarat, Ahmedabad
Petition No.: R/Special Civil Application No. 16339 of 2024
Date of Judgment: 29 January 2025
Category: Provisional Attachment – Input Tax Credit / Fraudulent Invoices
Relevant Sections: Section 83(1) & 83(2), Section 67, Section 70, Section 74 of CGST/GGST Act, Rule 159 of CGST Rules
Facts (Paras 4.1–4.15)
The petitioner, a sole proprietorship dealing in smartphones, was subjected to search under Section 67 on 17.10.2023 based on intelligence of circular trading and bogus billing. Multiple bank accounts and immovable property were provisionally attached under Section 83. Though the petitioner filed objections under Rule 159 and argued that attachments automatically ceased after one year under Section 83(2), the department renewed attachments in November and December 2024 citing ongoing investigations revealing a statewide scam involving 115 dealers and estimated fraud of ₹360 crore. The petitioner challenged the renewal, contending lack of jurisdiction, absence of fresh satisfaction, and violation of Supreme Court rulings in Radha Krishan Industries and RHC Global Exports.
Questions Before Court
-
Whether provisional attachment lapses after one year under Section 83(2) and cannot be renewed.
-
Whether the renewal orders dated 13.11.2024 and 18.12.2024 were without jurisdiction or fresh orders validly issued.
-
Whether the respondent authority at Vadodara had territorial jurisdiction over the petitioner based in Ahmedabad.
Observations (Paras 7–13)
The Court noted that the petitioner admitted during summons proceedings to indulging in cash purchases/sales and issuance of bogus invoices. Investigation showed manipulation of ITC by using cheaper phone invoices to offset liability on high-end phones without actual inward supply. Estimated liability was ₹18.97 crore (FY 2021–2024).
The Court distinguished Radha Krishan Industries, holding that in that case bogus invoices were received along with goods, whereas here invoices were issued without supply. It further held that while Section 83(2) limits an attachment’s life to one year, nothing prevents issuance of fresh orders with renewed satisfaction if investigation continues and liability is quantified. The satisfaction notes dated 13.11.2024 and 18.12.2024, though similar, were based on ongoing investigation and fresh quantification under Section 74(5).
Judgment (Paras 14–15)
The High Court held that the department acted within its powers under Section 83 to safeguard revenue. The renewal orders were treated as fresh provisional attachment orders, not illegal extensions. Given the petitioner’s prima facie involvement in fraudulent ITC claims causing revenue loss exceeding ₹18 crore, the attachments were justified. The petition was dismissed, and the provisional attachment of bank accounts continued.
Cases Referred
| Case | Court | Ratio / Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Radha Krishan Industries v. State of HP (2021) 6 SCC 771 | Supreme Court | Formation of opinion under Section 83 must be based on tangible material; attachment ceases after one year unless fresh satisfaction is recorded. |
| RHC Global Exports Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India (2024) 166 taxmann.com 730 | Supreme Court | Attachment beyond one year invalid if not supported by fresh satisfaction; banks must release accounts post expiry. |
| Mahakali Enterprises v. Union of India (2022) 142 taxmann.com 315 (Guj.) | Gujarat HC | Provisional attachment ceases after one year; bank operations must resume unless renewed lawfully. |
| Shree Dhanlaxmi Metal Industries v. State of Gujarat (2024) | Gujarat HC | Provisional attachment upheld where ITC fraud of ₹76 crore established; safeguards revenue. |
Between Fine Lines
This judgment reinforces that while Section 83 attachments automatically expire after one year, authorities can issue fresh orders if supported by new satisfaction notes and ongoing investigation. Businesses must note that procedural lapses like expiry do not automatically guarantee release if fraudulent activity is established. For traders, it signals that provisional attachments remain a potent revenue safeguard tool, particularly in cases of large-scale ITC fraud.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




