Home Case Laws Recovery Stayed After Pre-deposit Made for Appellate Tribunal Appeal

Recovery Stayed After Pre-deposit Made for Appellate Tribunal Appeal

0
411

Case Summary

Case Title: M/s Jyoti Tar Products Pvt Ltd & Anr. vs The Deputy Commissioner of State Tax, Shibpur Charge & Ors.
Court: High Court at Calcutta (Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction)
Petition No.: WPA 1352 of 2025
Date of Judgment: 07.04.2025
Category of Dispute: Recovery Proceedings after Appeal; Refund of Amount Recovered During Pendency
Relevant Sections:

  • Section 73, 107, and 112(8) & (9) of CGST Act, 2017

  • Section 143 of Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024

  • Circular No. 17/2024 dated 11.09.2024


Facts of the Case

[Para 1–4, 8]

  1. The petitioner challenged an order dated 24.11.2023 issued under Section 73 of the CGST/WBGST Act for the FY 2022–23.

  2. An appeal under Section 107 was filed and the mandatory 10% pre-deposit was duly paid (₹35,316).

  3. The appeal was dismissed on 24.12.2024. Petitioners then conveyed their intention to approach the Appellate Tribunal.

  4. Due to the Tribunal not being operational, an additional 10% pre-deposit of ₹35,316 was paid as per Section 112(8) read with Finance Act, 2024.

  5. Despite compliance, the department recovered ₹50,330 (₹342 from cash ledger + ₹49,988 from credit ledger) during January 2025.


Questions in Consideration

[Para 5–8]

  • Whether the recovery of ₹50,330 after deposit under Section 112(8) is valid?

  • Whether such recovery is prohibited by law and circulars when Appellate Tribunal is not constituted and pre-deposit is made?


Observations of the Court

[Para 6–8]

  1. The Court acknowledged the petitioners’ compliance with pre-deposit requirements under both Sections 107 and 112(8).

  2. As per CBIC Circular dated 11.07.2024 and WB Circular No. 17/2024 dated 11.09.2024, no further recovery is permissible when appeal to the Tribunal is pending and pre-deposit is made.

  3. The court noted that the Tribunal was not operational and thus, recovery was premature.

  4. Verified that ₹50,330 was indeed deducted from the petitioner’s electronic ledgers.


Judgment of the Court

[Para 9]

  • Without delving into the merits, the Hon’ble Court directed the department to verify the recovery and, if found true, re-credit the amount of ₹50,330 to the petitioner’s electronic cash and credit ledgers to be reflected in the May 2025 ledger.

  • Writ Petition was disposed of with liberty to approach the department.


✅ Between Fine Lines

  • A taxpayer who has filed an appeal and paid mandatory pre-deposit under Section 112(8) cannot be subjected to recovery.

  • CBIC and State circulars bar coercive recovery during pendency of appeal when the Tribunal is not operational.

  • Recovery made by debit of electronic cash/credit ledger during this period is illegal.

  • Court ordered refund through re-credit to the ledgers.

  • The case reinforces protection to taxpayers awaiting Tribunal constitution.


📄 Summary of Referred Cases

Case Name Citation Summary Verdict
No cases were judicially cited or relied upon in this matter — — —

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY