Home Case Laws Rectification of GSTR-1 Allowed Beyond Section 16(4) Limitation in Bonafide Error Case

Rectification of GSTR-1 Allowed Beyond Section 16(4) Limitation in Bonafide Error Case

0
365

Case Title: ESDS Software Solution Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner of Commercial Taxes
Court: High Court of Karnataka
Petition No.: WP No. 4211 of 2023
Category: Input Tax Credit
Judgment Date: 22 April 2025
Relevant Sections: Section 16(4) of the CGST Act, Circular No.183/15/2022-GST dated 27.12.2022
CGST Rules Referred: Rule 36(4), Rule 46


Facts of the Case (¶1–¶4)

The petitioner, ESDS Software Solution Ltd., had uploaded Form GSTR-1 for September 2020, showing invoices with Haryana as the place of supply instead of Uttar Pradesh, due to an inadvertent error in the addressee address. This prevented the recipient (Respondent No.6 – Larsen & Toubro Ltd.) from availing the ITC. Multiple representations were made to allow rectification, but the authorities rejected the request citing the time bar under Section 16(4) of the CGST Act.


Question(s) in Consideration (¶1, ¶4–¶5)

  • Whether rectification of GSTR-1 filed for FY 2020-21 can be permitted beyond the statutory limitation under Section 16(4) in case of bonafide error?

  • Whether Circular No.183/15/2022-GST (applicable to FY 2017-18 & 2018-19) can be extended to FY 2020-21?


Observations of the Court (¶7–¶10)

  • The Court referred to its prior ruling in Wipro Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner where the benefit of the circular was extended beyond FY 2018-19.

  • The Court noted that the Circular is meant to rectify bonafide mistakes like incorrect GSTIN, B2C vs B2B misreporting, or mismatched credit despite proper tax payment.

  • The petitioner had also filed affidavits and CA certifications per para 4.1.1 of the Circular, confirming tax was duly paid.

  • Respondent No.6 (L&T Ltd.) also confirmed the mismatch and supported the petitioner’s claim.


Judgment of the Court (¶18)

  • The Court allowed the petition.

  • Directed Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 (Revenue Authorities) to consider the request of the petitioner as per Circular No.183/15/2022-GST.

  • Ordered the rectification of GSTR-1 for FY 2020-21 to enable ITC to the recipient, treating the error as a bonafide and inadvertent mistake.


Between Fine Lines

  • Rectification of GSTR-1 can be allowed even beyond time limits if the error is bonafide.

  • Circular No.183/15/2022-GST can apply to post-2018-19 years based on court directions.

  • No ITC loss should occur to recipients due to supplier’s technical error.

  • Certification by CA and affirmation by recipient strengthens such petitions.

  • Courts adopt a justice-oriented approach to GST procedural lapses.


Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
Wipro Ltd. v. Asst. Commissioner WP No.16175/2022 Court extended Circular 183/15/2022 to FY 2019-20 Allowed rectification
Sun Dye Chem v. Asst. Commissioner WP No.29676/2019 (Madras HC) Error in IGST v. CGST/SGST column held bonafide Rectification allowed
Pentacle Plant Machineries v. GST Council WP No.1022/2020 (Madras HC) GSTIN mismatch – technical error allowed to be corrected Allowed petition
Star Engineers India v. Union of India WP No.15368/2023 (Bombay HC) GST credit denial due to GSTIN mismatch Correction directed
Shiva Jyoti Construction v. CBEC WP(C) No.18216/2017 (Orissa HC) Form B2C instead of B2B filed – allowed to correct Petition allowed
Mahalaxmi Infra Contracts Ltd. v. GST Council WP(T) No.2478/2021 (Jharkhand HC) Rectification allowed post-limitation due to system gaps Allowed rectification
Railroad Logistics v. Union of India WP(L) No.2429/2021 (Bombay HC) GSTIN mismatch case – correction permitted Petition allowed
Mahle Anand Thermal Systems v. Union of India WP No.117/2022 (Bombay HC) SAP system error – GSTIN wrongly updated Directed to decide representation
Screenotex Engineers v. Commissioner of CGST SCA No.9577/2020 (Gujarat HC) Deemed export mismatch – allowed GSTR-1 rectification Allowed correction

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY