Home Case Laws Refund denial set aside as Rule 89(4) was incorrectly invoked despite the...

Refund denial set aside as Rule 89(4) was incorrectly invoked despite the exporter having paid IGST on zero-rated supplies

0
284

OHMI Industries Asia Pvt. Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner, CGST

Delhi High Court | W.P.(C) 6856/2022 | Refund (Zero-Rated Supply – IGST Paid) | Date of Judgment: 29.03.2023
Relevant Provisions: Section 16 IGST Act; Rule 89(4) CGST Rules.


Facts of the Case (Paras 1–8)

The petitioner exported services in October 2018 and duly paid IGST of ₹12,02,165 on such zero-rated supplies. Foreign Inward Remittances were received in November 2018. A refund application of ₹3,99,187 (IGST paid) was filed on 29.05.2020.

A deficiency memo sought the FIRC, which the petitioner provided. Subsequently, a show-cause notice alleged differences in tax payment (Annexure B) and non-reflection of certain ITC entries in GSTR-2A for Aug–Oct 2018. Despite written clarifications by the petitioner, the adjudicating authority rejected the refund, holding that Rule 89(4)(D) mandates considering turnover of zero-rated services based on receipt of payment, which fell in another month.


Questions / Issues Before the Court

  1. Whether refund of IGST paid on export of services can be denied by applying Rule 89(4) of the CGST Rules when the exporter did not seek refund of accumulated ITC.

  2. Whether the adjudicating and appellate authorities erred by treating the refund as ITC refund even though the taxpayer sought refund of tax actually paid.

  3. Whether the date of receipt of consideration (November 2018) could justify denial of refund for October 2018 exports.


Observations of the Court (Paras 12–15)

The Court emphasised that Rule 89(4) applies only where exports are made without payment of tax under LUT/Bond, and refund pertains to accumulated ITC. The opening line of Rule 89(4) makes this explicit.

In this case, the petitioner had paid IGST, and there was no dispute that liability was discharged (para 8). Therefore, Rule 89(4) had no applicability.

The appellate authority mechanically rejected the appeal, incorrectly assuming that the claim pertained to accumulated ITC (para 13). The Court found the reasoning ex facie erroneous.


Judgment (Verdict) (Paras 15–18)

The High Court held that the refund rejection was unsustainable, as the authorities misapplied Rule 89(4). The order of the appellate authority was set aside, and the matter was remanded for fresh adjudication keeping in view the Court’s findings that Rule 89(4) does not govern refund of IGST paid on exports.


Case Law Table – Summary of Referred Principles

(This judgment does not cite external cases; table reflects internal findings)

Issue / Principle Court’s Holding Para Ref
Applicability of Rule 89(4) Applies only to LUT/Bond exports without tax payment Para 12
Refund nature Petitioner sought refund of IGST paid, not ITC Paras 10, 13
Error by authorities Erroneous assumption that ITC refund was sought Para 13
Final outcome Impugned orders quashed; matter remanded Paras 15–17

Between Fine Lines – Practical Takeaways for Trade

Exporters who pay IGST on export of services are not governed by Rule 89(4), which applies strictly to LUT/Bond cases involving unutilised ITC refunds. Denial of refund solely on the basis of receipt of consideration in another month is unsustainable where IGST was already discharged. Authorities must differentiate between “refund of tax paid” and “refund of ITC”, and cannot mechanically apply formulas meant for ITC refund categories.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY