Home Case Laws Refund denial under inverted duty structure quashed as circular imposing filing-date based...

Refund denial under inverted duty structure quashed as circular imposing filing-date based restriction held arbitrary and ultra vires

0
290

Case Details

Case Title: M/s Shree Proteins Private Limited v. Union of India & Anr.
Court: High Court of Gujarat, Ahmedabad
Petition No.: R/Special Civil Application No. 10677 of 2023
Judgment Date: 27 March 2025
Category of Dispute: Refund of Input Tax Credit (Inverted Duty Structure)
Relevant Sections: Section 54(1) & 54(3) of the CGST Act, 2017; Rule 89(5) of CGST Rules, 2017
Notifications & Circulars Involved: Notification No. 5/2017-CT (Rate), Notification No. 09/2022-CT (Rate), Circular No. 181/13/2022-GST dated 10.11.2022

Facts (Para 3)

The petitioner, engaged in manufacturing and trading edible oils under Chapter 15 HSN codes, supplied goods at 5% GST but procured inputs at higher rates (12%, 18%, 28%), resulting in accumulation of unutilized Input Tax Credit (ITC). Refund claims were filed under Section 54(3). Initially, refund was allowed as products were not restricted by Notification 5/2017-CT (Rate). However, Notification 09/2022-CT (Rate) dated 13.07.2022 included Chapter 15 products within the restricted category effective 18.07.2022. Refund applications for periods prior to July 2022 were rejected by the department relying on CBIC Circular No. 181/13/2022-GST dated 10.11.2022 (Paras 3.7–3.11).


Questions before the Court (Paras 4–5)

  • Whether Circular No. 181/13/2022-GST could restrict refund entitlement for periods prior to 18.07.2022 merely because the application was filed after that date.

  • Whether rejection of refund applications already eligible under Section 54(3) was lawful.


Observations (Paras 7–11)

The Court noted that refund rejections were solely based on Circular No. 181/13/2022. Referring to Patanjali Foods Ltd. v. Union of India and Ascent Meditech, the Court reiterated that circulars cannot override statutory rights under Section 54(1). Para 2(2) of the Circular created an artificial classification between assessees based on the date of filing refund applications even though claims pertained to periods prior to 18.07.2022. This was held discriminatory, violative of Article 14, and ultra vires Section 54 (Paras 11.4–11.6).


Judgment (Paras 12–13)

  • The Court struck down Para 2(2) of Circular No. 181/13/2022-GST as arbitrary and unconstitutional.

  • Rejection orders dated 20.01.2023, 30.01.2023, and 24.02.2023 were quashed.

  • Respondents were directed to process refund applications (Serial Nos. 1 to 7) within 12 weeks.

  • However, refund claim for Sept–Nov 2018 (Serial No. 8) was held barred by limitation as the last date to file was 25.10.2022. That rejection was upheld.

Outcome: Petition partly allowed. Refunds for eligible periods to be granted; time-barred claim rejected.


Table of Cases Referred

Case Court’s Verdict Relevance
Patanjali Foods Ltd. v. Union of India (2025) Struck down para 2(2) of Circular 181/2022 as ultra vires Section 54 Applied directly; petitioner’s case covered
Ascent Meditech v. UOI Held refund right cannot be denied based on filing date; quashed para 2(1) of same Circular Strengthened principle that circular cannot create artificial classification
Jenefa India v. UOI Clarified exemption/right cannot be curtailed by circulars under Section 168 Used in petitioner’s arguments
Pitambra Books Pvt. Ltd. v. UOI Held refund claim is a statutory right Cited to argue against denial by circular

Between Fine Lines (Practical Takeaway)

For manufacturers and traders facing inverted duty structure, this judgment ensures that refund claims filed within two years cannot be denied merely because they were filed after 18.07.2022. Circulars cannot retroactively restrict statutory rights. Industry players dealing in edible oils and similar goods must carefully track timelines, as only limitation under Section 54(1) governs eligibility, not the date of filing vis-à-vis notifications.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY