Home Case Laws Refund directed with 9% interest and costs as recovery under GST was...

Refund directed with 9% interest and costs as recovery under GST was held illegal and orders passed in disregard of binding precedent

0
235

Case: M/s Great Eastern Hire Purchase Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Bihar & Ors.

Court: Patna High Court
Petition: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 18049 of 2024
Category of Dispute: Refund with interest and costs (illegal recovery under GST)
Date of Judgment: 25 June 2025
Relevant Sections: Sections 62, 73, 74 of the CGST/BGST Act, 2017

Facts (Paras 2–7)

The petitioner, M/s Great Eastern Hire Purchase Pvt. Ltd., challenged two orders (Annexures P4 & P5) passed by the Assistant Commissioner and the Appellate Authority under the Bihar GST regime. These orders had confirmed tax demand and recovery despite the binding judgment of the Patna High Court in SIS Cash Services Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India (CWJC No. 6514 of 2021, decided 24.01.2024).

The Court, in its earlier order dated 06.05.2025 (paras 35–37), had quashed the impugned orders and issued show cause to the concerned officers (Respondent Nos. 5 and 6) as to why costs and contempt proceedings should not be initiated against them for disobedience.


Questions before the Court

  1. Whether the impugned orders of assessment and appeal rejecting petitioner’s claim despite a binding precedent were sustainable?

  2. Whether the officers concerned were liable for contempt and costs for disregarding judicial precedent?

  3. Whether the petitioner was entitled to refund with interest and compensation for wrongful recovery?


Observations (Paras 5–9)

  • The Assistant Commissioner (R-5) argued that the order was passed on the basis of portal entries and without knowledge of the judgment in SIS Cash Services.

  • The Appellate Authority (R-6) contended that the amnesty scheme under Notification No. 53/2023 dated 02.11.2023 was inapplicable since the order arose under Section 62, not under Sections 73 or 74.

  • Both respondents tendered unconditional apologies. Since their explanations remained uncontroverted by the petitioner, the Court refrained from pursuing contempt proceedings.


Judgment (Paras 10–16)

  • The State, through the Advocate General, agreed to refund the recovered amount with 9% simple interest from the date of recovery until refund.

  • The Court directed that such refund with interest must be made within six weeks.

  • Additionally, ₹10,000/- was imposed as costs payable to the petitioner.

  • The Court clarified that the State Government was at liberty to recover the interest and costs from the erring officials personally.

  • The writ petition was disposed of accordingly.


Case Law Referred

Case Citation Ratio / Verdict
SIS Cash Services Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India Patna HC, CWJC No. 6514 of 2021, decided 24.01.2024 Held that recovery without following due process under GST law is illegal; binding precedent disregarded by officers in present case.

Between Fine Lines

For taxpayers, this case highlights that illegal recoveries made by the department are not only refundable but also attract compensatory interest and costs. For tax officers, it underlines accountability—courts can direct personal recovery of costs and interest from erring officials. Businesses should promptly rely on judicial precedents in their representations to prevent unwarranted demands.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY