Case Title: Appario Retail (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India
Court: High Court of Telangana
Petition Number: Writ Petition No. 12183 of 2021
Category of Dispute: Refund – Excess Balance in Electronic Cash Ledger due to TCS
Date of Judgement: 28 September 2021
Relevant Sections: Sections 9, 49(1), 49(6), 52(1), 52(3), 52(7), 54(1) of CGST Act; Rule 89(2)(n) of CGST Rules
Facts of the Case [Paras 1–13]
- [Para 2–3] Appario Retail Pvt. Ltd. is a registered GST dealer engaged in trading electronic goods via e-commerce platforms. It maintains significant inventory and receives payments via the e-commerce operator (ECO).
- [Para 4–5] As per Section 52 of the CGST Act, the ECO deducts TCS (Tax Collected at Source) and deposits it with the Government, which is then credited to the petitioner’s electronic cash ledger.
- [Para 7] For October 2018, the petitioner claimed a refund of ₹1,17,29,989 from its electronic cash ledger (IGST: ₹73,08,531; CGST: ₹22,10,729; SGST: ₹22,10,729), which was sanctioned initially by the jurisdictional officer.
- [Para 8–9] The refund sanction was reviewed and appealed by the department citing non-compliance with the principle of unjust enrichment under Section 54.
- [Para 13] Due to the absence of a functioning GST Appellate Tribunal, the petitioner filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution.
Questions in Consideration [Paras 14–19]
- Whether refund of the balance in the electronic cash ledger comprising TCS deducted by the ECO is permissible under Section 54 of the CGST Act.
- Whether the amount deducted and deposited by the ECO qualifies as tax paid by the petitioner.
- Whether the petitioner can invoke writ jurisdiction in absence of the GST Appellate Tribunal.
Observation of the Court [Paras 20–52]
- [Paras 28–30] Section 49(1) allows any person (not necessarily the ledger-holder) to deposit amounts into an electronic cash ledger. Thus, TCS collected by ECO and credited to the petitioner qualifies.
- [Paras 32–35] TCS under Section 52 is collected from the supplier’s receivables and is treated as a ‘tax’ deposited in the supplier’s (Appario’s) electronic cash ledger.
- [Paras 39–42] Refund under Section 54(1) is bifurcated: one for tax/interest paid by “any person” and another under the proviso for a “registered person” claiming refund of balance in electronic cash ledger – the latter applies here.
- [Paras 43–45] The petitioner’s refund pertains to excess electronic cash ledger balance – not tax incidence or unjust enrichment. FAQs and Circular No. 125/44/2019/GST support this view.
- [Paras 46–49] CBIC circulars issued under Section 168 are binding on departmental officers. The department’s appeal and the appellate order contrary to CBIC clarifications are invalid.
- [Paras 50–51] Reliance placed on Kerala HC ruling in Royale Edible Co. allowing refund of unutilized TCS amount in electronic cash ledger. The court also upheld writ maintainability due to the absence of an appellate forum.
Judgement of the Court [Paras 52–54]
- The impugned appellate order denying refund is set aside.
- The petitioner is entitled to refund of ₹1,17,29,989 for October 2018 from its electronic cash ledger.
- The writ petition is allowed, holding that the petitioner rightfully claimed refund under the proviso to Section 54(1) of the CGST Act.
Between Fine Lines
- TCS amounts deposited by ECOs into the supplier’s electronic cash ledger are deemed as tax paid and refundable.
- Refund under Section 54’s proviso doesn’t require the petitioner to prove unjust enrichment.
- CBIC circulars bind departmental officers and appellate authorities.
- Refund claims can be entertained via writ petitions when no appellate tribunal exists.
- Functional absence of GST Tribunal cannot bar a genuine refund due under the law.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| Royale Edible Co. v. UOI | WP(C) No. 22593 of 2020, Kerala HC | Refund of TCS excess in e-cash ledger allowed, subject to offsetting dues | Allowed refund |
| Commissioner of Customs v. IOC | 2004 taxmann.com 1061 (SC) | CBEC circulars are binding on officers under the statute | Circulars held binding |
| Cognizance for Extension of Limitation | 2020 SCC OnLine SC 343 | Limitation period extended due to COVID for judicial processes | Extension upheld |
Takeaway
“TCS Deposited by Others, But Refund Rightfully Yours”




