Case Summary: Truth Fashion v. Commissioner of Delhi Goods & Services Tax Act
Delhi High Court | W.P.(C) 324/2024 | Refund – Deficiency Memo – Expeditious Disposal
Judgment dated 10.01.2024
Case Classification (GST Act, 2017)
Category: Refund under CGST/SGST Act
Relevant Provisions:
-
Section 54, CGST Act – Refund
-
Rule 90, CGST Rules – Deficiency Memo
-
Rule 92, CGST Rules – Order on Refund Application
Facts of the Case (Paras 1–3)
The petitioner, Truth Fashion, approached the Delhi High Court seeking a direction for sanction of refund of ₹18,33,000, claimed for the tax period April 2022 – March 2023.
The application for refund was submitted on 08.10.2023.
During the hearing, the Revenue informed the Court that a deficiency memo dated 08.01.2024 had already been issued and a personal hearing was scheduled for 17.01.2024 (para 2, ).
The petitioner, however, submitted that no deficiency memo had been received (para 3, ).
Questions Before the Court
-
Whether the petitioner was entitled to a direction for refund of GST when the refund process had not been completed by the department.
-
Whether the department was required to furnish the deficiency memo and expedite refund adjudication.
Court’s Observations (Paras 2–6)
The Court noted that although the Revenue claimed to have issued a deficiency memo on 08.01.2024, the same had admittedly not reached the petitioner.
The Court recorded the Revenue’s assurance that the deficiency memo would be furnished during the course of the day (para 4, ).
The Court also took note of the delay in completion of the refund process despite the application having been filed on 08.10.2023, and held that once the deficiency memo stands served, the adjudication must be completed within a reasonable timeline.
Judgment / Verdict (Paras 5–7)
The writ petition was disposed of, with liberty to the petitioner to revive the matter if needed (para 5).
Further, the Court issued a specific direction to the department to expedite the adjudication of the refund application and endeavour to dispose of it within four weeks from the date of the order (para 6, ).
The Court also ensured immediate communication of the deficiency memo to the petitioner the same day (para 4).
Cases Referred – With Summary Table
No external case law was cited or referred to in this order.
Between the Fine Lines – Practical Takeaways for Trade
The order underscores that GST refund proceedings cannot be kept pending indefinitely. Even if a deficiency memo is issued, it must be properly served, and once served, the department is expected to complete the refund adjudication quickly. Taxpayers may approach the High Court when refunds are delayed or deficiency memos are not communicated timely.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




