Case: J&K Cement Corporation v. Union of India & Ors.
Court: High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh at Jammu
Petition: WP(C) No. 2188/2022
Judgment Date: 04.04.2025 (Reserved on 17.03.2025)
Category of Dispute: Refund under Budgetary Support Scheme
Relevant Sections: Section 49(1) CGST Act, 2017; Section 20 IGST Act, 2017; Notification No. 05.10.2017 (Ministry of Commerce & Industry)
Facts (Paras 1–6)
The petitioner, J&K Cement Corporation, an industrial unit manufacturing cement, earlier enjoyed excise refund benefits under Notifications 56/2002-CE and 1/2010-CE. With GST rollout, these exemptions were rescinded via Notification 21/2017-CE. To compensate, the Government introduced the Budgetary Support Scheme, 2017 through Notification dated 05.10.2017, allowing eligible units to claim refunds of 58% of CGST and 29% of IGST paid in cash.
The petitioner filed refund claims for July–Sept 2021 and Jan–Mar 2022. While refund of Rs. 6,64,181 was sanctioned for the earlier period, for Jan–Mar 2022, Rs. 4,41,919 was granted against a claim of Rs. 4,44,114. A sum of Rs. 2,195 was rejected without reason, prompting the writ petition.
Questions Before Court
-
Whether the rejection of Rs. 2,195 from the refund claim was legally sustainable under the Budgetary Support Scheme, 2017.
-
Whether Respondent No.3 (Deputy Commissioner, CGST, Samba) had the authority to reduce the claim without transparent calculation or reasoning.
Observations (Paras 7–15)
The Court noted that:
-
The petitioner’s eligibility under the scheme was undisputed (Para 9).
-
Notification dated 05.10.2017 prescribes refund strictly as 58% of CGST paid in cash after ITC utilization and 29% of IGST paid similarly (Para 11).
-
For cement (Chapter 25), the excise notification mandates 75% value addition, which was satisfied by petitioner’s payment (Paras 12–15).
-
Respondents did not disclose the basis of their computation nor justified the rejection of Rs. 2,195 (Paras 7, 12, 15).
The Court held that petitioner’s calculation of Rs. 4,44,114 was correct and supported by scheme provisions.
Judgment (Paras 16–18)
The Court concluded that rejection of Rs. 2,195 was arbitrary, unjustified, and contrary to Notification 05.10.2017. It directed Respondent No.3 to release the balance refund of Rs. 2,195. The writ petition was disposed of accordingly.
Case Law Reference Table
| Case Referred | Court’s Finding | Relevance in Present Case |
|---|---|---|
| Excise Exemption Notifications 56/2002-CE & 1/2010-CE | Provided refund/exemption benefits pre-GST | Formed basis of eligibility for budgetary support |
| Notification 21/2017-CE | Rescinded earlier excise exemptions | Led to introduction of Budgetary Support Scheme |
| Notification 05.10.2017 (Budgetary Support Scheme) | Prescribed 58% CGST & 29% IGST refund post ITC | Central to petitioner’s entitlement |
Between Fine Lines (Practical Takeaway)
Industrial units availing budgetary support cannot be denied refund arbitrarily or on undisclosed calculations. Even small rejections must be reasoned, else they will be struck down as contrary to the scheme’s express provisions. This strengthens trade confidence that budgetary support benefits under GST are enforceable rights, not discretionary grants.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




