Home Case Laws Refund rejection quashed as Court held that denial of small amounts under...

Refund rejection quashed as Court held that denial of small amounts under budgetary support scheme was arbitrary and contrary to notification

0
273

Case Summary

Case Title: Shiva Industries v. Union of India & Ors.
Court: High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh at Jammu
Petition No.: WP(C) No. 2159/2022
Date of Judgment: 04.04.2025 (Reserved on 17.03.2025)
Category: Refund – Budgetary Support under CGST regime
Relevant Sections: Section 49(1) of CGST Act, 2017; Section 20 of IGST Act, 2017; Notification No. F.No.10(1)2017-DBA-II/NER dated 05.10.2017


Facts (Paras 1–6)

The petitioner, Shiva Industries, is engaged in the manufacture and supply of cement. Before GST, it availed excise refunds under Notifications No. 56/2002 and 1/2010. After rescission of these notifications post-GST, the Union introduced a Budgetary Support Scheme via Notification dated 05.10.2017 to extend partial refund of CGST/IGST to eligible units.
The petitioner applied for refunds for July–September 2021 and January–March 2022. The Deputy Commissioner sanctioned most of the claims but rejected small portions (₹1,678 and ₹7,170) without reasons.


Questions before Court (Paras 6–7)

  1. Whether partial rejection of refund without disclosing calculation basis was sustainable.

  2. Whether denial of refund contradicted the clear formula under Notification 05.10.2017.


Observations (Paras 8–15)

  • The Court noted that petitioner’s eligibility under the scheme was undisputed.

  • Notification 05.10.2017 clearly prescribes that budgetary support is 58% of CGST paid in cash and 29% of IGST paid in cash, post ITC utilization (Para 11).

  • The rejection lacked reasoning and the respondents failed to explain their calculation method (Para 12–13).

  • On recalculating, Court held petitioner’s claims matched the formula, and denial of the small residual refund was unjustified (Paras 14–15).


Judgment (Paras 16–18)

The High Court quashed the rejection of ₹1,678 and ₹7,170, holding it contrary to Notification 05.10.2017. The respondents were directed to release the disallowed amounts along with sanctioned refunds. The writ petition was disposed of accordingly.


Case Law Table

Case Referred Court’s Verdict Relevance
Notification No. 05.10.2017 (Budgetary Support Scheme) Eligible units entitled to 58% of CGST and 29% of IGST paid in cash post ITC utilization Basis for refund computation and rejection found contrary to it
Notification No. 1/2010-CE & 56/2002-CE Provided excise refunds pre-GST, rescinded later Demonstrated petitioner’s eligibility under budgetary support scheme

Between Fine Lines

For industries in J&K covered under the Budgetary Support Scheme, authorities cannot arbitrarily reject portions of refund claims without justification. Even minor disallowances must strictly follow the formula prescribed in the notification, else such denial will be struck down by courts.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY