Globus Real Infra refund rejection remanded as appellate authority failed to consider whether lease stood nullified under approved resolution plan
Case Title
Globus Real Infra Pvt. Ltd. v. Additional Commissioner, CGST Appeals-II
Court
High Court of Delhi
Petition No.
W.P.(C) 2083/2023 with CM Nos. 7918/2023, 7919/2023, 7920/2023
Date of Judgment
17 February 2023
Category of Dispute under GST
Refund under Section 54 of CGST Act, 2017 – GST paid on lease rentals during CIRP; effect of IBC resolution plan on taxability.
Relevant Provisions
-
Section 54, CGST Act – Refund
-
Section 15, CGST Act – Valuation
-
Section 7 & 9, CGST Act – Scope of supply and levy
-
Section 43, Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code – Preferential transactions
-
Lease Agreement dated 01.04.2015 nullified under approved Resolution Plan
-
Clause 10.1.16 of Resolution Plan (termination of related-party contracts)
FACTS OF THE CASE
(Paras 1–10 of judgment)
The petitioner had leased out its farm property to Bhushan Steel Limited (BSL) under an agreement dated 01.04.2015. Subsequently, BSL underwent CIRP upon an application by SBI under Section 7 of the IBC (paras 2–4). The Resolution Professional classified the lease as a related-party preferential transaction under Section 43 of the Code. A Resolution Plan submitted by Tata Steel was approved by the CoC on 20.03.2018 and later by the NCLT on 15.05.2018 (para 5).
Due to non-payment of lease rent, the petitioner sold the property in September 2018. On 18.11.2020, it filed a refund application under Section 54 seeking refund of GST paid on lease rentals for July 2017–July 2018 (para 7). The adjudicating authority issued a SCN and eventually rejected the refund on 06.04.2021 on the premise that GST remained payable even if consideration was not realized (paras 8–9, 14).
The first appellate authority dismissed the appeal on 31.03.2022, leading to the present writ petition (para 10).
QUESTIONS / ISSUES BEFORE THE COURT
Derived from paras 11–12 & 17–19.
-
Whether the refund rejection order violated principles of natural justice.
-
Whether the authorities failed to consider the petitioner’s foundational contention that the lease itself stood terminated under the approved Resolution Plan, thereby extinguishing the underlying taxable supply.
-
Whether GST remained payable when the underlying related-party lease agreement was nullified under Clause 10.1.16 of the Resolution Plan approved by NCLT.
COURT’S OBSERVATIONS
(Paras 13–20)
The Court noted that the adjudicating authority rejected the refund solely on the reasoning that GST is payable on supply irrespective of realization of consideration, referencing Sections 7, 9, 13, and 15 (paras 13–14).
On natural justice, the Court held that the petitioner was granted multiple hearings on 23.02.2022, 14.03.2022 and 24.03.2022, and repeated adjournment requests could not bind the authority. Hence no violation existed (paras 15–16).
Crucially, the Court held that the appellate authority failed to address the petitioner’s main submission:
-
Clause 10.1.16 of the resolution plan mandated termination of all related-party agreements without liability, which included the lease (paras 17–19).
-
If the lease stood terminated under the IBC-approved resolution plan, the basic premise of “supply of service” under GST was in doubt.
-
The appellate authority ignored this vital contention and merely proceeded on the basis that supply was admitted and refund was sought only due to non-recovery of lease rent (para 19).
The Court found this a substantive non-application of mind.
JUDGMENT / VERDICT
(Paras 20–21)
The High Court set aside the impugned appellate order and remanded the matter to the appellate authority with a direction to:
-
consider the petitioner’s contention regarding nullification of the lease under the Resolution Plan;
-
determine whether the very supply existed; and
-
pass a speaking order after granting reasonable opportunity of hearing.
All pending applications were disposed of.
SUMMARY OF CASES REFERRED (as required)
| Case / Reference | Issue Considered | Court’s Holding | Relevance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Resolution Plan of BSL under IBC approved by NCLT (15.05.2018) | Termination of related-party agreements including lease | Clause 10.1.16: All related-party contracts to be terminated without liability | Central to determining whether taxable “supply” subsisted |
| IBC s.43 finding of preferential transaction | Classification of lease as preferential | Lease treated as related-party arrangement | Provides basis that lease was voidable/terminated |
(No other external case law is cited in the judgment.)
BETWEEN FINE LINES (Practical Takeaways for Trade)
When a contract forming the basis of GST levy is terminated through an IBC-approved resolution plan, authorities must first determine whether the underlying taxable supply survives. GST cannot be levied in vacuum when the contractual foundation is extinguished by operation of insolvency law. Refund cannot be rejected merely by invoking non-realization of consideration without examining the survival of the supply itself.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




