Case Summary
Case Title: M/s Tirth Agro Technology Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. v. Union of India & Ors.
Court: High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad
Petition No.: R/Special Civil Application Nos. 11630, 11635, 11647 & 11649 of 2023
Category of Dispute: Refund of unutilised ITC under inverted duty structure
Date of Judgment: 20/12/2024
Relevant Sections: Section 54(1) & 54(3) of CGST Act, 2017; Rule 89(5) of CGST Rules, 2017
Relevant Notifications / Circulars: Notification No. 14/2022-CT dated 05.07.2022, Circular No. 181/22/2022-GST dated 10.11.2022
Facts (Paras 3–6, 15–16)
The petitioner, a manufacturer, claimed refund of unutilised input tax credit (ITC) under Section 54(3) of the CGST Act for periods 2019–2020. Refunds were partly sanctioned using the old Rule 89(5) formula which excluded input services. After Notification No. 14/2022 amended Rule 89(5) effective 05.07.2022, the petitioner filed rectification applications for additional refund. The Department rejected these citing CBIC Circular 10.11.2022, which treated the amendment as prospective.
Questions for Consideration
-
Whether the amendment to Rule 89(5) vide Notification No. 14/2022 is clarificatory/curative or prospective?
-
Whether refund claims already filed before 05.07.2022 but within two years are entitled to recomputation under the amended formula?
Observations (Paras 7–14, 17–18)
The Court noted the Apex Court’s ruling in Union of India v. VKC Footsteps (2022) 2 SCC 603, which upheld Rule 89(5) but directed the GST Council to correct anomalies. Pursuant to this, the Council recommended an amendment and Notification 14/2022 was issued. Although CBIC circular stated the amendment is prospective, Gujarat High Court in Ascent Meditech Ltd. v. UOI (SCA 18317/2023, decided 17.10.2024) had already held it to be clarificatory and applicable retrospectively.
The Court emphasized that denying refund to pre-05.07.2022 applicants would cause discrimination between similarly placed taxpayers, contrary to Section 54(1) & (3).
Judgment (Paras 18–19)
The Court followed Ascent Meditech and held Notification No. 14/2022 to be clarificatory and curative, applicable retrospectively to refund claims filed within two years. The impugned rejections were set aside, and respondents directed to release differential refund amounts (column 10 of chart) within three months.
Cases Referred (with verdicts)
| Case | Court & Citation | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Union of India v. VKC Footsteps India Pvt. Ltd. (2022) 2 SCC 603 | Supreme Court | Upheld validity of Rule 89(5) but urged GST Council to amend formula due to anomalies. |
| Collector of C. Ex., Shillong v. Wood Craft Products Ltd. (1995) 3 SCC 454 | Supreme Court | Held clarificatory notifications operate retrospectively. |
| Ascent Meditech Ltd. v. Union of India (SCA 18317/2023, 17.10.2024, Gujarat HC) | Gujarat HC | Held Notification 14/2022 is clarificatory and retrospective; refunds within Sec. 54 time limit must be recomputed. |
| Shree Renuka Sugars Ltd. & Pee Gee Fabrics Ltd. | Gujarat HC | Allowed second refund claims if filed within limitation. |
Between Fine Lines
For businesses facing inverted duty structure, this judgment ensures a level playing field by allowing refunds based on the amended formula even for claims filed before 05.07.2022, provided they were within two years. It prevents revenue authorities from creating artificial cut-off dates and confirms that curative amendments must benefit all eligible taxpayers.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




