Case Title: Varshan Enterprises v. Office of GST Council
Court: High Court of Andhra Pradesh
Petition Number: Writ Petition No. 10637 of 2021
Category of Dispute: Refund – Error in GSTR-1 recipient details
Date of Judgement: 9th December 2022
Relevant Sections:
Section 54, CGST Act, 2017
Rule 97A, CGST Rules, 2017
Article 226 & 265 of the Constitution of India
Section 72, Indian Contract Act, 1872
Section 17, Limitation Act, 1963
Facts of the Case (¶2–¶5)
- The petitioner, Varshan Enterprises, a GST-registered telecom pipe-laying contractor, rendered services to Vodafone Mobile Services Ltd., Kandlakoya, Telangana but mistakenly uploaded recipient details in GSTR-1 as Vodafone, Mumbai (GSTIN: 27AAACS4457Q1ZQ) for FY 2018.
- The error resulted in the actual recipient being unable to claim ITC, and the petitioner was denied rectification due to the system’s cut-off date (20-10-2019) being exceeded.
- A refund or adjustment request was denied by the Superintendent, CGST, citing Circular No. CBEC-20/16/04/18-GST dated 18-11-2019 under Section 54.
- The petitioner argued the error was inadvertent and invoked Section 72 of the Contract Act and Article 265 of the Constitution to claim unjust enrichment by the Revenue.
Question(s) in Consideration (¶8)
Whether the petitioner is entitled to a writ of mandamus to:
- Set aside the CGST Superintendent’s communication dated 26-02-2021, and
- Permit rectification of GSTR-1 details for June 2018 or allow refund of ₹7,87,328.78.
Observations of the Court (¶12–¶26)
- Acknowledgment of Error (¶12–¶14): Court noted the error was genuine and due to human mistake during portal data entry. The petitioner discovered the mistake only in May 2020.
- Rule 97A Overrides Circular (¶14–¶16): The 2019 Circular cannot override Rule 97A which allows manual refund filing. The petitioner’s claim does not fall under categories requiring e-filing only.
- Precedents (¶17–¶23): The Court relied on decisions including:
- Pentacle Plant Machineries (Madras HC) – allowed correction in GSTR-1.
- Laxmi Organic Industries (Bom HC) – held that Rule 97A permits manual refund.
- Mafatlal Industries (SC) – held no unjust enrichment permissible under Section 72 of Contract Act.
- On Limitation (¶24): The Court held that the limitation under Section 54 is not applicable for amounts wrongly paid due to error and not legally due. Instead, Section 17 of the Limitation Act is relevant.
- Doctrine of Impossibility (¶24): The petitioner could not be compelled to perform an act (rectification through the portal) which the system rendered impossible.
Judgement of the Court (¶27)
The writ petition was allowed.
- The communication of the Superintendent of CGST dated 26-02-2021 was set aside.
- The petitioner was permitted to file a manual refund application, which must be processed within four weeks in accordance with law.
Between Fine Lines:
- A taxpayer who makes a genuine clerical error in GSTR-1 cannot be denied rectification or refund merely because of system restrictions.
- Manual filing under Rule 97A prevails over electronic restrictions imposed by CBIC circulars.
- Refund claims for amounts wrongly paid due to error are governed by principles of unjust enrichment, not just Section 54.
- The Revenue cannot retain taxes paid by mistake when not due legally.
- Circulars cannot override statutory rules; taxpayer rights are preserved under Article 265 and Section 72 of Contract Act.
Summary of Referred Cases:
| S.No. | Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| 1 | Pentacle Plant Machineries (P.) Ltd. | 52 GSTL 129 (Madras HC) | Allowed correction of incorrect GSTIN in GSTR-1 due to absence of enabling mechanism. | In favour of petitioner |
| 2 | Commissioner v. Shriram Transport Finance | 124 taxmann.com 341 (Bom HC) | Recovery of tax without authority is invalid. | In favour of assessee |
| 3 | Mafatlal Industries Ltd. v. Union of India | 111 STC 467 (SC) | Doctrine of unjust enrichment – money paid under mistake must be refunded. | In favour of taxpayer |
| 4 | Vasudha Bommireddy v. Asstt. CST | W.P. No. 5980 of 2017; 2020-TIOL-397-HC-AP-ST | Refund denied for being beyond limitation under Section 11B of CE Act. | Against petitioner |
| 5 | Cosmol Energy (P.) Ltd. v. State of Gujarat | 127 taxmann.com 736 (Gujarat HC) | Refund allowed where tax was collected without authority; Section 54 not applicable. | In favour of petitioner |
| 6 | Laxmi Organic Industries Ltd. v. UOI | 133 taxmann.com 65; 89 GST 463 (Bom HC) | Rule 97A overrides Circular; manual filing allowed for refund applications. | In favour of petitioner |
| 7 | Union of India v. VKC Footsteps India (P.) Ltd. | 130 taxmann.com 193 (SC); 2022 2 SCC 603 | Relied upon by Revenue; held limitation under Section 54 is valid and binding. | Against petitioner |
Takeaway:
Human Error Shouldn’t Nullify Taxpayer’s Right: Refund Claim Not Barred by Portal Constraints




