Home Case Laws Restoration Permitted Upon Compliance with GST Filing Post-Cancellation

Restoration Permitted Upon Compliance with GST Filing Post-Cancellation

0
224

 

Case Title: Nipunjay Basumatary v. State of Assam & Ors.
Court: Gauhati High Court
Petition Number: WP(C)/1955/2025
Relevant Section: Section 29(2)(c), Rule 22(4) of CGST Rules, Section 39(1), Section 73(10), Section 44
Category of Dispute: GST Registration Cancellation & Revocation
Date of Judgment: 08-April-2025
Relevant CGST/AGST Provisions: Section 29(2)(c), Section 39(1), Rule 22(1) to 22(5), Section 73(10), Section 44


📘 Facts of the Case (¶2–¶4)

  • The petitioner, a GST-registered sole proprietor, did not file returns for six months, leading to a show cause notice dated 07.11.2019 under Section 29(2)(c) of the CGST Act (¶2).

  • A cancellation order was passed ex parte on 19.11.2019 without any personal hearing date being communicated (¶2).

  • Petitioner was not aware due to unfamiliarity with the GST portal and missed the response window (¶3).

  • Subsequent attempt to file revocation was barred as the 270-day deadline had lapsed. Appeal to the Joint Commissioner (Appeals) was also rejected on 06.12.2024 (¶4).


⚖️ Question(s) in Consideration (¶5–¶7)

  • Whether the cancellation of GST registration without granting personal hearing and refusal to allow revocation due to time lapse can be revisited in light of the petitioner’s willingness to comply.

  • Whether the proviso to Rule 22(4) allows restoration upon filing returns and payment of dues.


🔍 Observations of the Court (¶9–¶11)

  • Court emphasized the proviso to Rule 22(4): if all returns are filed and dues paid, proceedings can be dropped via Form GST REG-20 (¶9).

  • Refers to Sanjoy Nath v. Union of India (WP(C) 6366/2023) where similar relief was granted (¶10).

  • Court highlighted the civil consequences of cancellation and opined that restoration must be allowed if petitioner complies fully with dues and filing obligations (¶11).


🧾 Judgment of the Court (¶12–¶14)

  • Court directed petitioner to approach the GST officer within 2 months and comply with Rule 22(4) proviso (¶12).

  • Upon full compliance (returns + dues + interest + late fees), authority shall consider restoration as per law (¶12).

  • Limitation under Section 73(10) shall be counted from this judgment date (except for FY 2024-25, governed by Section 44) (¶14).


🧠 Between Fine Lines:

  1. GST cancellation was procedurally flawed due to lack of a personal hearing.

  2. Revocation timeline had expired, but Court offered a remedial route under Rule 22(4) CGST Rules.

  3. Restoration is conditional upon complete tax compliance.

  4. Civil consequences of cancellation influenced judicial leniency.

  5. Judgment offers relief for genuine taxpayers facing procedural hardship.


📚 Summary of Referred Cases:

Name Citation Summary Verdict
Sanjoy Nath v. Union of India WP(C) No. 6366/2023 (Gauhati HC) Petitioner similarly suffered cancellation due to non-filing; Court allowed restoration if tax dues were paid Relief granted on compliance basis

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY