INFINITY INFOMATIC PRIVATE LIMITED v. COMMISSIONER OF DELHI GST & ANR.
Delhi High Court | W.P.(C) 13120/2023 | Category: GST Registration Cancellation | Issue: Retrospective Cancellation | Order dated: 09.10.2023
Relevant Provisions: Section 29(2) CGST Act, Rule 21, Rule 22 CGST Rules.
Facts of the Case
(Paras 1–9)
The petitioner challenged an order dated 09.08.2021 cancelling its GST registration with retrospective effect from 01.07.2017. The Department had issued a show-cause notice (SCN) dated 09.07.2021 alleging that the petitioner issued invoices without actual supply, leading to wrongful availment/utilisation of ITC. However, the SCN did not specify any invoice number, period, value, parties involved, or quantum of alleged wrongful ITC.
The SCN also required appearance before the proper officer but did not mention any date or time, and the GST registration was simultaneously suspended. The petitioner did not respond, citing closure of business in April 2021 due to the pandemic and the death of one promoter.
The impugned cancellation order merely recorded “no reply received” without assigning any independent reason for retrospective effect or dealing with allegations in the SCN. The petitioner did not contest cancellation per se, but only the retrospective period.
Questions of Law / Issues
(Paras 8–12)
-
Whether a GST registration can be cancelled retrospectively without issuing a SCN containing specific grounds, particulars, and alleged contraventions?
-
Whether an unreasoned cancellation order, merely stating “no reply filed,” satisfies the requirement of a speaking order under Section 29(2) and Rule 22?
-
Whether retrospective effect can be imposed without putting the assessee to notice regarding the proposed retrospective period?
Observations of the Court
(Paras 8–12)
The Court observed that the SCN lacked particulars, rendering it impossible for the petitioner to respond meaningfully. The SCN did not identify any allegedly fake invoices or quantify wrongful ITC. The Court also noted that retrospective cancellation was never proposed in the SCN, depriving the assessee of an opportunity to address this severe consequence.
Further, the impugned order was unreasoned, as it only recorded non-filing of reply without any findings on allegations, statutory basis, or justification for retrospective effect. The Court reiterated that retrospective cancellation cannot be exercised mechanically, especially when it impacts ITC chains and third-party transactions, and must be supported by cogent reasoning.
Judgment / Final Decision
(Paras 11–14)
The Delhi High Court set aside the retrospective cancellation, holding that both the SCN and the cancellation order were defective. The Court directed that cancellation shall take effect only from April 2021, which aligns with the admitted closure of business.
The Court clarified that the Department remains free to:
-
issue a fresh SCN if it proposes retrospective cancellation, and
-
initiate recovery proceedings for any tax, interest, or penalty, strictly in accordance with law.
Case Law / Authorities Referred (and Role)
(Only those appearing in the uploaded file; none expressly cited by Court. Table created for completeness.)
| Case Referred | Court | Verdict / Principle | Relevance in Present Case |
|---|---|---|---|
| No external precedents cited in judgment | – | – | The Court relied on settled principles of natural justice and requirements of a valid SCN and reasoned order under GST law. |
Between the Fine Lines – Practical Takeaways for Trade
This ruling reinforces that the Department cannot cancel GST registration retrospectively unless the notice clearly spells out specific allegations, invoice details, time period, and intention to cancel retrospectively. A mechanical or template SCN will not survive judicial scrutiny. Businesses should challenge retrospective cancellation unless backed by a speaking order, as such orders may disrupt ITC flow and expose them to unwarranted liabilities.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




