Home Case Laws Retrospective GST cancellation beyond the date of business closure held unjustified as...

Retrospective GST cancellation beyond the date of business closure held unjustified as the cancellation order lacked cogent reasons and suffered from internal contradictions, warranting modification of the effective date to the date of proprietor’s death.

0
156

Case Classification under GST Act, 2017

Category: Cancellation of Registration / Retrospective Cancellation
Relevant Provisions: Section 29(2) of CGST Act, 2017; Section 39; GST Registration Rules


Facts of the Case (Paras 1–10)

The petitioner, Ashish Garg, legal heir of Late Sh. Pawan Kumar, challenged the order dated 14.03.2023, by which the GST registration of M/s Kirti Plastics was cancelled retrospectively from 28.05.2018. The Show Cause Notice (SCN) dated 15.01.2023 alleged non-filing of returns under Section 39.

The petitioner argued that the late proprietor had regularly filed returns and carried on business until early 2021, and subsequently died on 15.08.2021. The SCN was uploaded only on the portal and not physically served.

The cancellation order inconsistently recorded that no reply was filed, yet simultaneously referred to a reply dated 15.02.2023. The order also recorded nil dues, creating ambiguity as to whether any tax liability existed.

The grievance focused on retrospective cancellation, which prevented the legal heir from recovering cash ledger balances of approximately ₹55,000 total in CGST and SGST.


Questions / Issues for Determination

  1. Whether the GST registration could be retrospectively cancelled from 28.05.2018 without clear reasons or justification?

  2. Whether mechanical cancellation under Section 29(2) is permissible when the taxpayer was compliant for most periods?

  3. Whether the date of cancellation should align with the cessation of business on account of proprietor’s death?


Court’s Observations (Paras 6–14)

The Court held that neither the SCN nor the cancellation order stated any reason for retrospective cancellation. The order itself contained contradictions—claiming both presence and absence of reply.

The Court emphasised that retrospective cancellation cannot be mechanical under Section 29(2). The proper officer must record an objective satisfaction based on circumstances that justify retrospective effect.

Merely missing returns cannot justify retrospective cancellation extending to periods where compliance existed. The Court also noted the serious consequences for customers who may lose input tax credit when such retrospective cancellation is imposed (Paras 11–12).

Critically, the SCN never proposed retrospective cancellation, thereby failing principles of natural justice.

Both parties ultimately desired cancellation, though for different reasons, but the effective date required judicial correction (Para 14).


Judgment / Final Order (Paras 15–19)

The Court modified the cancellation order to provide that GST registration stands cancelled w.e.f. 15.08.2021, the date of the proprietor’s demise — not 28.05.2018.

The Court permitted the petitioner to seek refund/adjustment of the electronic cash ledger balance, directing authorities to consider such application in accordance with law (Para 16).

Authorities were not precluded from pursuing lawful recovery proceedings for any outstanding tax dues (Para 17).

Questions relating to succession were left open for adjudication by the competent authority (Para 18).


Between the Fine Lines (Practical Industry Takeaways)

This judgment reinforces that retrospective GST cancellation is an extraordinary measure, not a default consequence of non-filing. It must be supported by objective reasons, communicated through a properly drafted SCN. Officers cannot retrospectively cancel registrations for compliant periods, especially when such cancellation adversely affects ITC of recipients or cash ledger recovery of taxpayers. Importantly, where business cessation is due to events like death of proprietor, cancellation must be aligned with actual discontinuance of business.


Table: Cases Referred & Their Verdicts

(This judgment does not explicitly cite external case law. Hence, the table records internal findings only.)

Reference Context in Judgment Principle / Verdict
Court’s internal reliance on Section 29(2) CGST Act Requirement of objective criteria for retrospective cancellation (Paras 11–12) Retrospective cancellation cannot be mechanical; must be based on objective reasons, and SCN must expressly propose retrospective effect.

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY