Home Case Laws Retrospective GST cancellation quashed as the Show Cause Notice failed to put...

Retrospective GST cancellation quashed as the Show Cause Notice failed to put the taxpayer to notice of retrospective effect and because registration had already ceased upon the taxpayer’s own cancellation application.

0
215

CASE SUMMARY

Case Title: Aryan Timber Store Through Its Prop. Virender Kumar v. Sales Tax Officer Class II/AVATO Ward 62, Department of Trade & Taxes
Court: High Court of Delhi
Petition: W.P.(C) 628/2024 & CM Appl. 2749/2024, 2748/2024
Date of Judgment: 18.01.2024
Category: GST Registration Cancellation – Retrospective Cancellation
Statutory Provisions: Section 29(2) of the CGST Act, 2017


FACTS (Paras 1–6)

The petitioner’s GST registration was cancelled by order dated 09.07.2022, retrospectively from 01.07.2017.
The petitioner had discontinued business w.e.f 31.03.2019 and applied for cancellation on 06.05.2019.

A Show Cause Notice dated 15.07.2021 alleged non-filing of returns for six months and sought explanation as to why registration should not be cancelled. However, the Notice did not disclose that retrospective cancellation was proposed.

Records showed that the petitioner’s application for cancellation had already been filed and pending, and once business was discontinued, there was no occasion to continue filing returns.

Nonetheless, the proper officer cancelled the registration retrospectively to 01.07.2017 solely on the ground of non-filing of returns.


QUESTIONS FOR DETERMINATION

  1. Whether cancellation of GST registration could lawfully be ordered retrospectively without the Show Cause Notice specifically proposing retrospective effect.

  2. Whether retrospective cancellation could be justified when the taxpayer had already discontinued business and applied for cancellation.

  3. Whether non-filing of returns after discontinuation of business could constitute a valid ground for retrospective cancellation.


OBSERVATIONS OF THE COURT (Paras 3–8)

The Court held that the SCN merely alleged non-filing of returns but did not put the petitioner to notice regarding retrospective cancellation. Therefore, the petitioner had no opportunity to object to such retrospective effect.

The Court emphasised that Section 29(2) CGST Act permits retrospective cancellation only if the proper officer records satisfaction based on objective criteria. Such power cannot be exercised mechanically.
Non-filing of returns, by itself, does not justify retrospective cancellation, especially for periods in which the taxpayer was compliant.

The Court took note of the respondents’ submission that retrospective cancellation affects buyers’ input tax credit, implying that retrospective cancellation has serious consequences and therefore must be exercised cautiously and only where warranted.

Because the petitioner had already applied for cancellation on 06.05.2019 and had stopped business on 31.03.2019, there was no obligation to file returns thereafter; hence cancellation on the ground of return default was factually unsustainable.


JUDGMENT / VERDICT (Paras 9–10)

The High Court modified the cancellation order and held that GST registration shall stand cancelled only from 06.05.2019, the date of the petitioner’s cancellation application.

The respondents were permitted to pursue recovery of any tax, interest, or penalty strictly in accordance with law.
The writ petition was disposed of accordingly.


SUMMARY OF CASES REFERRED (TABULAR FORM)

The judgment does not cite or rely upon any external precedents.
Thus, the table is intentionally left with “None cited”.

Case Name Court / Citation Issue Verdict
None cited in the judgment — — —

BETWEEN THE FINE LINES (Trade / Industry Takeaways)

The ruling reiterates that retrospective cancellation of GST registration cannot be imposed casually. Departments must explicitly propose retrospective effect in the SCN and provide the taxpayer an opportunity to respond. Retrospective cancellation directly affects recipient ITC and hence cannot be invoked merely due to return defaults, especially where the taxpayer has already ceased business and applied for cancellation. Officers must demonstrate objective satisfaction and proportionality before invoking Section 29(2).

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY