Case Summary
-
Case Title: Indian Medical Association Kerala State Branch v. Union of India & Ors.
-
Court Name: High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam
-
Petition Numbers: W.A. No.1659/2024, W.A. No.1487/2024, W.A. No.468/2025
-
Relevant Sections: Section 2(17)(e), Section 7(1)(aa), Explanation to Section 7(1), Article 246A, Article 366(12A) of Constitution
-
Category: Constitutional Validity – Supply between Association and Members under GST
-
Date of Judgment: 11 April 2025
-
Relevant CGST/SGST Provisions: Section 2(17)(e), 7(1)(aa), and Explanation to Section 7(1), Finance Act, 2021
Facts of the Case [¶2–¶4, ¶6, ¶41]
The Indian Medical Association (IMA), Kerala, filed a writ petition seeking protection from GST demands on mutual benefit schemes it runs for its member doctors (e.g., Social Security, Disability, Legal Aid, Pension). They were served summons seeking details for FY 2017–2022. IMA argued that the principle of mutuality applied to such schemes, making them non-taxable. The 2021 amendment to Section 7(1) and its retrospective application from 01.07.2017 imposed a GST burden on these schemes.
Question(s) in Consideration [¶5, ¶11]
-
Whether Sections 2(17)(e), 7(1)(aa), and the Explanation under the CGST/KGST Acts are unconstitutional for taxing mutual benefit schemes between associations and their members.
-
Whether retrospective application of these provisions from 01.07.2017 violates constitutional principles of fairness, reasonableness, and legislative competence.
Observations of the Court
-
On Constitutionality [¶13–¶17, ¶22–¶23]:
The Constitution under Article 246A read with Article 366(12A) does not permit taxation on “self-supply.” Supply and service inherently involve two separate persons, and the principle of mutuality excludes such distinction. Since the definition of “service” was not amended to override this, deeming association and members as separate entities for tax is unconstitutional. -
On Legislative Competence [¶14–¶18]:
The Court held that a legislature cannot override constitutional understanding through statutory fiction. Deeming amendments in Finance Act, 2021, lacked constitutional support and legislative competence. The 46th Constitutional Amendment was cited as precedent for what must be constitutionally amended and cannot be altered by statute. -
On Retrospectivity [¶24–¶25]:
Retrospective taxation imposed a disproportionate burden and violated the rule of law. The IMA did not collect GST from members during the period 2017–2022, creating financial hardship. The retroactive effect lacked justification and fairness.
Judgment of the Court [¶24–¶25, Last Page]
-
Held:
Sections 2(17)(e), 7(1)(aa), and the Explanation thereto under the CGST Act and KGST Act are declared unconstitutional and void as ultra vires Article 246A read with Article 366(12A) and Article 265 of the Constitution.
W.A. No.1659/2024 (IMA’s appeal) allowed.
W.A. No.1487/2024 and W.A. No.468/2025 (Government appeals) dismissed.
No costs.
Between Fine Lines
-
Clubs and associations cannot be taxed under GST for services to their own members due to the mutuality principle.
-
CGST amendments attempting to treat associations and their members as separate entities are unconstitutional.
-
Constitution must be amended, not just the statute, to create such a levy.
-
Retrospective GST demands from 2017 are invalid and unenforceable.
-
The judgment is a significant relief for charitable and mutual benefit associations.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Calcutta Club Ltd. v. State of WB | (2019) 19 SCC 107 | Held principle of mutuality survives even after 46th Amendment | Relied on for mutuality principle |
| Ranchi Club v. CC of C. Ex. & ST | 2012 SCC OnLine SC 306 | Held that no service exists between club and members under mutuality | Relied on |
| Young Men’s Indian Assn. v. CTO | (1970) 1 SCC 462 | Clubs not separate from members; no sale to members | Cited as background to Article 366(29A) |
| Jayam & Co. v. Asst. Commr. | (2016) 15 SCC 125 | Held retrospective curtailment of ITC is impermissible | Relied on to contest retroactive levy |
| Navnit Lal Javeri v. A.A.C. | (1965) 56 ITR 198 (SC) | Deemed dividend upheld as “income” under I.T. law | Distinguished |
| Skill Lotto v. Union of India | (2021) 15 SCC 667 | Actionable claims may be defined as “goods” | Distinguished |
| Lalta Prasad v. State of U.P. | 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3029 (9J Bench) | Entries must be interpreted widely, but consistent with constitutional limits | Cited by Revenue; not accepted |
| Exide Industries v. Union of India | (2020) 5 SCC 274 | Legislature may amend statutes to overcome judgments | Cited by Revenue; held insufficient here |
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




