State of Maharashtra v. LM Wind Power Blades India Pvt. Ltd.
High Court of Bombay
Writ Petition No. 6968 of 2019; Interim Application No. 1779 of 2021; Review Petition (Stamp) No. 98390 of 2020
Category: Refund under GST / Bank Guarantee Encashment
Date of Judgment: 04 October 2021
Relevant Sections: Sections 54, 56, 107, 112, 115, 129 CGST Act; Section 21 IGST Act; Article 226 of Constitution of India
Facts of the Case
[Para 5–8, 23–25]
- The petitioner had submitted eight bank guarantees totaling ₹4.73 crore to the department in a case related to tax demands under Section 129 of the CGST Act.
- These bank guarantees were encashed by the department after an order dated 26.03.2019 from the Appellate Authority, even though the petitioner had sought time to appeal to the GST Appellate Tribunal (which was non-functional at the time).
- The petitioner claimed that a total of ₹7.80 crore was lying with the government, whereas their maximum liability even if all appeals failed would only be ₹1.65 crore.
- The petitioner sought refund of the amount covered by the encashed guarantees, stating the action violated principles laid down in Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. v. Union of India.
Question(s) in Consideration
[Para 6–7, 9]
- Whether the State was justified in encashing unconditional bank guarantees when the appeal window was still open.
- Whether refund could be ordered under Article 226 when excess amount was held by the tax authorities.
- Whether such refund claims must mandatorily follow Section 54 CGST procedure.
- Whether review of the previous judgment (dated 15.09.2020) could be entertained under Section 114 CPC.
Observations of the Court
[Para 23–30]
- The Court held that a total of ₹7.80 crore (including tax, pre-deposit, and bank guarantee encashment) was with the authorities against a maximum potential liability of ₹1.65 crore.
- The Court observed that under Sections 107 and 112 of CGST Act, a taxpayer is required to make specific pre-deposits to avail appeal remedy, and such pre-deposit stays recovery under Section 112(9).
- Citing Section 115, the Court emphasized that excess payments made during the appellate process must be refunded with interest under Section 56.
- The Court found the encashment unjustified especially when the appeal process was contemplated and no opportunity for appellate remedy existed due to non-constitution of the Tribunal.
Judgment of the Court
[Para 30–31]
- The Court directed the respondents to refund ₹4,73,26,512 (covered by the eight bank guarantees) along with applicable statutory interest within four weeks.
- The petitioner was directed to furnish fresh bank guarantees of ₹1,65,64,279 covering the balance liability.
- The review petition was later dismissed on 04.10.2021, holding that there was no error apparent on record, and grounds raised were fit for appeal, not review under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC.
Between Fine Lines
- The Court protected taxpayer rights when excessive funds were held by the department post pre-deposit and encashment.
- Refunds of amounts paid under duress or overlapping heads can be ordered under writ jurisdiction in exceptional circumstances.
- Functioning of appellate tribunals is critical to avoid such litigation.
- The unconditional nature of bank guarantees did not override statutory appellate rights.
- The review petition failed as it sought a re-argument on already adjudicated issues.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. v. UOI | 59 ELT 505 | Action taken during appeal period despite assurance not to enforce | Held impermissible |
| LM Wind Power v. State of Maharashtra | [2020] 120 taxmann.com 29 | Original judgment ordering refund of bank guarantee encashment | Writ allowed; refund granted |
Takeaway
“Encashing Without Appeal Exhaustion Violates Natural Justice”




