Case Title: Tvl. Lucky Mydeen Briyani v. Commissioner
Court: High Court of Madras
Petition Number: W.P (MD) No. 20035 of 2022
Category: GST Registration Cancellation
Date of Judgement: August 29, 2022
Relevant Sections: Section 29(2)(c) of CGST Act
Relevant Rules/Notifications: Circular from Commissioner dated 07.04.2021 in P/35/2021-ADC (RC AND M)-CCT-CTD
Facts of the Case
- The petitioner, proprietor of Tvl. Lucky Mydeen Briyani, failed to file GST returns for a continuous period of six months during the COVID-19 pandemic due to business closure and ill health, and was unaware of registration cancellation due to accountant’s control over GST portal access (Para 1).
- The GST registration was cancelled via order dated 04.01.2022. The petitioner attempted to file a revocation request but missed the 90-day deadline (Para 2).
- The petitioner relied on a circular issued by the Commissioner (dated 07.04.2021) and judicial precedent (Tvl. Suguna Cutpiece Center) to argue for exclusion of COVID-related period from limitation computation (Para 3).
Question(s) in Consideration
- Whether the delay in filing the application for revocation of GST registration, due to COVID-19 and illness, can be condoned?
- Whether the petitioner is entitled to restoration of registration despite procedural default in revocation filing?
(Para 3, 5)
Observations of the Court
- The Court noted that the petitioner’s situation closely resembled that in Tvl. Suguna Cutpiece Center, where delay was condoned under similar grounds, keeping in mind the principle of facilitating GST compliance and avoiding undue hardship (Para 5).
- It held that allowing revival serves the revenue’s interest, as it ensures future tax compliance and prevents tax leakage from unregistered operations (Paras 216–220).
- The safeguards from the precedent judgment were reiterated to prevent misuse—requiring tax and interest payments in cash, filing of past and future returns, and scrutiny of ITC before utilization (Paras 229.i–x).
Judgement of the Court
The writ petition was allowed. The GST registration of the petitioner shall be revived subject to compliance with the safeguards laid down in Tvl. Suguna Cutpiece Center, including:
- Filing pending returns and tax payments in cash (not via ITC),
- Subjecting all ITC to scrutiny before use,
- Compliance within 45 days from receipt of the order,
- Directions to GSTN to facilitate portal access for return filing and payment.
(Para 6)
Between Fine Lines
- GST registration cancellation during the pandemic can be challenged if procedural default was due to bona fide reasons.
- Courts are inclined to restore registration to bring taxpayers back under the GST regime.
- Taxpayers must comply with specific safeguards to prevent ITC misuse.
- Delay in revocation filing may be condoned based on judicial and administrative directions.
- Restoration enables continued legitimate trade and tax contribution.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| Tvl. Suguna Cutpiece Center v. Appellate Deputy Commissioner (ST) (GST) | [2022] 135 taxmann.com 234 / 91 GST 77 / 61 GSTL 515 | Delay in revocation/appeal was condoned due to COVID-19; emphasized re-integrating dealers into GST regime with conditions | Delay condoned; Registration restored |




