Home Case Laws Royalty is separate and distinct from the land revenue.

Royalty is separate and distinct from the land revenue.

0
597

Case Title: Shree Basant Bhandar Int. Udyog Chak v. Union of India

Court: High Court of Rajasthan

Petition No.: D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 5678 of 2022 and connected matters

Category of Dispute: Levy of GST on Royalty and DMFT Contribution

Date of Judgement: 29 September 2022

Relevant Sections: Section 9 of CGST Act, 2017

Relevant Rules: Not specifically cited

Facts of the Case

A bunch of writ petitions was filed challenging the levy of GST on royalty paid to the Mining Department under respective mining leases by the petitioners

 

In ten of these writs, an was additional issue raised regarding GST levy on contributions made to the District Mineral Foundation Trust (DMFT)

 

Petitioners argued that the coordinate bench’s prior decision in Sudershan Lal Gupta Contractor v. Union of India merely followed earlier rulings concerning service tax on royalty and failed to examine GST applicability on merits

Questions in Consideration

  1. Whether GST is leviable on royalty payments made to the State for mining rights under GST laws.
  2. Whether GST is also leviable on contributions made to DMFT.

Observation of Court

  1. The Court acknowledged that the judgment in Sudershan Lal Gupta Contractor had already decided the issue of GST on royalty, thereby concluding that issue
  2. It noted that petitioners still have a statutory right to respond to show cause notices or file appeals against final orders under the GST framework
  3. On the issue of GST on DMFT contributions, the Court allowed petitioners in ten specified writ petitions to continue contesting this point as it had not been conclusively adjudicated

Judgement of the Court

  1. The Court dismissed the writ petitions challenging GST on royalty, following the binding precedent in Sudershan Lal Gupta Contractor
  2. However, in petitions where the GST demand on DMFT contribution was also raised, the Court deferred judgment to allow further consideration on that specific issue

Between Fine Lines

  • GST is validly leviable on royalty paid for mining rights, as previously settled.
  • Petitioners may still use statutory remedies under GST laws for their individual cases.
  • GST levy on DMFT contributions remains undecided and open to challenge.
  • The judgment reaffirms the binding effect of coordinate bench rulings.
  • Procedural rights like filing replies and appeals remain unaffected by the writ dismissal.

Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
Sudershan Lal Gupta Contractor v. Union of India [2022] 143 taxmann.com 147 Challenge to GST on royalty; dismissed based on prior rulings without merit discussion. Followed
Udaipur Chambers of Commerce & Industry v. Union of India [2017] 87 taxmann.com 246 Dealt with service tax on royalty pre-GST era. Relied Upon
Mateshwari Minerals v. Union of India WP No. 7650/2021 (26-7-2021) Similar issue of service tax on mining royalty. Relied Upon
Shivalik Silica v. Union of India [2022] 58 GSTL 403 Service tax demand on royalty challenged. Relied Upon
Rajasthan Small Mines Lease Holders Assn. v. State of Rajasthan WP No. 5199/2022 (28-4-2022) Addressed levy of service tax on royalty. Relied Upon

 

Download Judgement

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY