Home Updates Calcutta High Court Grants Relief under Section 16(5) in Santu Das v....

Calcutta High Court Grants Relief under Section 16(5) in Santu Das v. Assistant Commissioner of CGST

0
150

The Calcutta High Court, in Santu Das v. Assistant Commissioner of CGST & Central Excise, Chandannagore Division & Others, delivered an important judgment concerning the retrospective benefit of Section 16(5) of the CGST/WBGST Act, eligibility of Input Tax Credit (ITC), GSTR-2A mismatch, voluntary tax payment and consequential penalty proceedings. The Court examined whether the introduction of Section 16(5) altered the validity of demands raised for delayed availment of ITC and considered the treatment of other disputed issues requiring factual verification.

The dispute arose from proceedings under Section 73 relating to the financial years 2017-18 and 2018-19. The tax authorities had raised demands alleging delayed availment of ITC, excess ITC due to mismatch between GSTR-3B, GSTR-9 and GSTR-2A, and short payment of tax. The adjudicating authority confirmed the demand and imposed penalty, while the appellate authority further enhanced the penalty in departmental appeal.

GST

A significant aspect of the judgment concerns the retrospective operation of Section 16(5). The High Court held that where the taxpayer had filed the relevant returns within the period contemplated under the newly inserted provision, the demand raised solely on the ground of delayed availment of ITC under Section 16(4) could no longer survive. Consequently, the Court quashed that portion of the demand.

With respect to the alleged mismatch of Input Tax Credit arising from non-reflection of invoices in GSTR-2A, the taxpayer contended that the supplier, Aircel, had entered insolvency proceedings and the failure to upload returns could not be attributed to the recipient despite payment of tax. Since the issue involved factual and legal examination, particularly in view of pending litigation relating to the supplier, the Court remanded the matter to the proper officer for fresh consideration.

The Court also considered the allegation of short payment of tax. As the taxpayer relied upon a voluntary payment made through Form GST DRC-03 before the proceedings, the Court held that the factual verification should be undertaken afresh by the adjudicating authority instead of being conclusively decided in writ jurisdiction.

Since the principal demand relating to delayed availment of ITC had been set aside, the enhanced penalty imposed by the appellate authority also could not be sustained. The Court accordingly set aside the penalty orders and remanded the issue of penalty for fresh adjudication after reconsideration of the surviving disputes.

Why Read This Judgment?

This decision is significant for taxpayers, Chartered Accountants, Advocates and GST practitioners dealing with disputes involving retrospective application of Section 16(5), delayed availment of Input Tax Credit, GSTR-2A mismatches, supplier default, voluntary tax payments through DRC-03 and penalty proceedings under Section 73. The judgment demonstrates how subsequent legislative amendments may materially affect pending assessments and appellate orders while emphasizing the need for fresh adjudication where factual issues remain unresolved.

Download

LEAVE A REPLY