Best Crop Science SCN upheld despite delay, as Section 67(7) consequences limited only to return of seized goods and not invalidation of notice
Case Title, Court, Petition No., Date & Category
-
Case Title: Best Crop Science Pvt. Ltd. v. Superintendent, CGST, Delhi West & Ors.
-
Court: High Court of Delhi
-
Petition Number: W.P.(C) 238/2023
-
Date of Judgment: 05 September 2023
-
Relevant Provision: Section 67(2) & 67(7) of the CGST Act (Inspection, Search, Seizure, Limitation)
-
Category of Dispute: Search & Seizure – Limitation for SCN & Validity of Prohibition Order
FACTS (Paras 1–8)
The petitioner challenged two searches conducted on 05.05.2022 and 26.08.2022 under Section 67(2) of the CGST Act. The Department initially issued a prohibition order on 26.08.2022, restraining the petitioner from dealing with certain goods. A seizure order was later issued on 21.09.2022.
During pendency of the writ petition, the Department issued a SCN dated 01.03.2023, which the petitioner argued was barred by limitation under Section 67(7) because it was allegedly issued more than six months after the prohibition order. Eventually, the petition was confined only to the challenge to the SCN.
The petitioner contended that goods must be returned as the SCN was issued belatedly and that the searches were illegally conducted without “reason to believe.”
The Revenue argued that the goods were seized only on 21.09.2022, and the SCN of 01.03.2023 was within six months. It also emphasized that confiscation order had already been passed on 29.05.2023, which is challenged in separate proceedings.
ISSUES / QUESTIONS (Paras 8–12 & 21)
-
Whether the period of six months under Section 67(7) for issuance of notice is to be computed from the prohibition order or from the seizure order?
-
Whether a prohibition order under the first proviso to Section 67(2) amounts to “seizure” for the purpose of applying limitation under Section 67(7)?
-
Whether issuance of notice beyond six months invalidates the SCN itself?
-
Whether the petitioner is entitled to return of goods solely due to delay in issuance of SCN?
OBSERVATIONS OF THE COURT (Paras 9–21)
On Nature of Prohibition vs Seizure (Paras 9–13, 19)
The Court clarified that:
-
Under Section 67(2), a prohibition order is not a temporary measure; it is meant only for circumstances where physical seizure is not practicable.
-
A prohibition order is effectively a form of constructive seizure, as held through analogy to Customs Act jurisprudence (Para 19).
-
The officer must have reason to believe that goods are liable to confiscation even before issuing a prohibition order.
On Limitation under Section 67(7) (Paras 16–21)
-
Citing Devesh Radheshyamji Kabra (Gujarat HC), the Court affirmed that non-issuance of notice within six months results only in the consequence that goods must be returned.
-
Delay does not invalidate the SCN; Section 67(7) does not prescribe a limitation period for validity of SCN (Para 21).
-
The Court relied heavily on Mohd. Salman Khan (Delhi HC) under the Customs Act to interpret that “detention vs seizure” distinction is not permitted; if goods are restrained, the law treats it as seizure.
On Confiscation Order (Para 20)
-
Since the Department had already passed a confiscation order on 29.05.2023, the issue of return of goods could not be considered in this writ; that remedy lies in the other pending petition.
JUDGMENT (Paras 20–23)
The Court held:
-
The SCN is not invalid merely because it was issued after six months of the prohibition order.
-
The only statutory consequence under Section 67(7) is that the goods may be returned, not that the SCN becomes void.
-
Since a confiscation order already exists and is under challenge separately, no direction for return of goods can be granted in this proceeding.
-
The writ petition was disposed of with all rights reserved for the petitioner’s separate challenge to the confiscation order.
TABLE OF CASES REFERRED
| Case | Court | Principle Held | Relevance to Present Case |
|---|---|---|---|
| Devesh Radheshyamji Kabra v. State of Gujarat | Gujarat High Court | Failure to issue notice within 6 months under Section 67(7) mandates return of seized property | Cited to interpret Section 67(7) and its consequence |
| Mohd. Salman Khan v. Union of India | Delhi High Court | Under Customs Act, detention is effectively seizure; SCN must be issued within 6 months | Used to interpret similarity of seizure/prohibition under GST |
| Golden Cotton Industries v. Union of India | Gujarat High Court | “Secreted” goods and permissibility of prohibition | Distinguished; not applicable to issue of limitation under Section 67(7) |
BETWEEN FINE LINES (Trade-Friendly Explanation)
This ruling clarifies that delayed issuance of a notice after search or seizure does not invalidate the SCN. The only remedy for delay is return of goods, and even that becomes unavailable if the Department has already passed a confiscation order. Businesses must therefore challenge confiscation orders directly rather than relying solely on limitation defects in SCN issuance. Prohibition orders are treated as constructive seizure, invoking the same statutory scheme as physical seizure.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




