Home Case Laws SCN uploaded under the tab ‘Additional Notices and Orders’

SCN uploaded under the tab ‘Additional Notices and Orders’

0
354

Case Details:

Particular Details
Case No. WP (C) No. 6758 of 2024 
Case Name Ace Cardiopathy Solutions (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India
Court Delhi High Court
Date of Judgement 10-05-2024

 

Issue- In the above case, the petitioner contended that Show Cause Notices are normally uploaded on the portal under the heading of ‘Notices’, however, in the instant case it appeared that the Show Cause Notice was uploaded on the portal in the category of ‘Additional Notices’ which were not easily accessible, and accordingly skipped the attention of the petitioner. He prayed that one opportunity be granted to the petitioner to respond to the Show Cause Notice and an opportunity of a personal hearing be also given.

 

Held – Keeping in view th judgements passed by various high courts, it was held that perusal of the impugned order shows that the impugned order categorically records that the taxpayer has not replied or appeared in person. Consequently, the petitioner needs to be granted one opportunity to respond to the Show Cause Notice and thereafter, the Show Cause Notice to be re-adjudicated.

 

Case Details:

Particular Details
Case No. WP (C) No. 7436 of 2024 
Case Name Udayraj Yadav v. Sales Tax Officer
Court Delhi High Court
Date of Judgement 22-05-2024

 

Issue- In the above case, the petitioner challenged the order and contended Show Cause Notice was uploaded on the portal in the category of ‘Additional Notices’ and was not communicated to the petitioner through any other mode of communication. The petitioner also submitted the manual copy given by the Department in the web portal. Since the Notices and the Orders were hosted in the Dashboard of the petitioner meant for “Additional Notices and Orders”, the petitioner failed to notice and file a reply to the Show Cause Notice.

Held – The impugned order was set aside. Since the only reason for passing the impugned order is that Petitioner had not filed any reply/explanation, Petitioner needs to be granted one opportunity to respond to the Show Cause Notice and thereafter, the Show Cause Notice to be re-adjudicated.

 

Case Details:

Particular Details
Case No. WP NO. 10598 and; 10602 of 2024
Case Name TVL. M.S. ENTERPRISES v. STATE TAX OFFICER
Court Madras High Court
Date of Judgement 23-04-2024

 

Issue – Upon receipt of the show cause notice, the petitioner submitted replies and the impugned orders were issued thereafter on 13.12.2023. He also pointed out that a personal hearing was expressly requested for however, order was passed.

 

Held –  The failure of the respondent to provide a personal hearing in spite of an express request for a personal hearing vitiates the impugned orders. Thus, the orders are quashed and the matters are remanded for reconsideration.

LEAVE A REPLY