Home Case Laws Second GST demand proceedings quashed as the Court held that issuing a...

Second GST demand proceedings quashed as the Court held that issuing a fresh DRC-07 for the same period was without jurisdiction when the earlier order was already under appeal, and rectification under Section 161 was the proper legal route.

0
235

W.P.(MD) No.18365 of 2025 — Madras High Court (Madurai Bench) — Order dated 07.07.2025

Category: Jurisdiction & Procedural Validity — Second GST DRC-07 proceedings; Section 161 rectification
Relevant Provisions: Sections 73, 161 of the TNGST/CGST Act; Rule 142 of CGST Rules.


Facts (with para references)

The petitioner, M/s JR Enterprises, was earlier subjected to an adverse assessment order in Form GST DRC-07 dated 30.11.2024 for the tax period April 2020–March 2021 (para 3). That order had already been appealed before the Appellate Commissioner (paras 3 & 4).

Despite this, the department initiated fresh proceedings by issuing a new DRC-01 dated 25.11.2024, culminating in a second DRC-07 dated 13.02.2025, with a summary order issued on 14.02.2025 (para 2).

The petitioner thereafter filed an application dated 03.04.2025 seeking rectification under Section 161 to cure the jurisdictional defect, but the authority rejected it on 29.04.2025, citing the Supreme Court decision in Satyanarayan Laxminarayan Hegde (AIR 1960 SC 137), holding that no “error apparent” existed (para 2).

The petitioner therefore approached the High Court seeking quashing of both the second DRC-07 and the refusal to rectify the defect.


Questions Before the Court (with para references)

  1. Whether initiation of a second set of proceedings under Form GST DRC-07 for the same period and same discrepancies is legally permissible when the earlier order is already under appeal? (paras 3 & 4)

  2. Whether the rejection of the rectification application under Section 161 dated 29.04.2025 was justified? (paras 2 & 4)


Observations (with para references)

The Court noted that the entire dispute for the same period had already culminated in an earlier DRC-07 order dated 30.11.2024, which was pending in statutory appeal (para 3).

It emphasised that there is no scope for initiation of a second or parallel assessment proceeding when an earlier order is already operative and sub-judice (para 4).

If there was an “error apparent on the face of the record,” the proper course was rectification under Section 161, which could be invoked by the department suo motu rather than by issuing a fresh DRC-01 and DRC-07 (para 4).

The Court held that the rejection of the taxpayer’s Section 161 application was incorrect, as the authority failed to appreciate that the second proceeding itself was fundamentally without jurisdiction (para 4).

Recognising that the Appellate Commissioner possesses wide statutory powers to consolidate and correct the demand, the Court suo motu impleaded the Appellate Authority (para 4).


Judgment (with para references)

The Court quashed the impugned DRC-07 dated 13.02.2025, its summary dated 14.02.2025, and the rejection order dated 29.04.2025 (para 4).

It directed the Appellate Commissioner to:

  • consider the entire issue,

  • incorporate any permissible demand arising from the alleged discrepancies, and

  • pass a consolidated and reasoned order after granting full opportunity of hearing (para 4).

The writ petition was accordingly disposed of (para 5).


Table of Cases Referred

Case Name Issue Considered Verdict / Principle
Satyanarayan Laxminarayan Hegde v. Mallikarjun Bhavanappa Tirumale (AIR 1960 SC 137) Meaning of “error apparent on the face of the record” Error must be self-evident; if it requires elaborate reasoning, Section 161 rectification cannot be invoked.

Between Fine Lines (Practical Trade Takeaways)

This judgment reinforces that the department cannot issue multiple DRC-07 orders for the same period, especially when the earlier order is under statutory appeal. Any perceived mistake must be corrected only through Section 161 rectification, not through re-assessment. Businesses facing duplicated demands now have clear grounds to seek quashing of such orders and insist on consolidation before the appellate authority.

LEAVE A REPLY