Home Case Laws Second Refund Application was rejected for the same refund if there is...

Second Refund Application was rejected for the same refund if there is some error on the part of Assessee.

0
508

Case Title: Hardik Textiles v. State of Gujarat

Court: High Court of Gujarat

Petition No.: R/Special Civil Application No. 7468 of 2021

Category of Dispute: Refund – Accumulated Input Tax Credit

Date of Judgement: 22nd December 2021

Relevant Sections: Section 54(3), CGST Act, 2017; Section 54(3), SGST Act, 2017; Section 73(5), CGST/SGST Act, 2017

Coram: Hon’ble Ms. Justice Sonia Gokani and Hon’ble Ms. Justice Nisha M. Thakore

 

Facts of the Case

[Para 3 to 3.5]

  • The petitioner, engaged in manufacturing, claimed refund of accumulated ITC under Section 54(3) of the CGST/SGST Acts.
  • A refund application (RFD-01) was filed for August 2018 to February 2020 through their GST consultant.
  • Refund payment order (RFD-05) dated 28-09-2020 was issued, but mistakenly credited to M/s. Meet Textiles due to erroneous bank details input by the consultant.
  • M/s. Meet Textiles returned ₹7,59,531 to the government via DRC-03 on 09-12-2020.
  • A second refund application was filed on 07-02-2021 under the “Others” category but was rejected again on 25-03-2021, prompting the present petition.

 

Question(s) in Consideration

[Para 1 & 2]

  • Whether the petitioner, due to a consultant’s error, can be deprived of a legitimate refund despite the amount having been restored to the government?
  • Whether the authorities can be directed to re-credit the refund amount to the petitioner’s correct bank account?

 

Observations of the Court

[Paras 6 to 10]

  • The Court acknowledged that the consultant’s mistake led to the incorrect credit, and the petitioner delayed redressal by about three months.
  • It was noted that the refunded amount was voluntarily returned by M/s. Meet Textiles through DRC-03.
  • The authorities were informed but due to system limitations, the refund was denied when re-applied under “others”.
  • The Court accepted that it was a technical glitch, and the petitioner should not suffer for an error not attributable to him.
  • The refund should be credited without requiring a new application, and any delay beyond 4 weeks would attract 12% interest.

 

Judgement of the Court

[Para 10 & 11]

  • The Court directed the authorities to credit the refund amount to the petitioner’s correct bank account within four weeks.
  • No further manual application is necessary.
  • Failure to do so within the stipulated time would result in interest at 12% p.a. from the date of the second application (07-02-2021).
  • The petition was disposed of accordingly.

 

Between Fine Lines

  1. A taxpayer cannot be penalized for an inadvertent mistake of their consultant when the refund amount was restored to the government.
  2. Refund rejections due to technical glitches must be resolved administratively and not used to deny legitimate claims.
  3. Once the erroneous credit is reversed, the system should allow refund reprocessing without insisting on new applications.
  4. Courts can direct refunds and impose interest where authorities fail to act reasonably.
  5. Fair conduct of parties and rectified errors should not result in denial of substantive relief.

 

Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
None cited – – –

 

Takeaway:

“When System Errors Override Substantive Rights – Refund Restored by Judicial Hand.”

LEAVE A REPLY