Home Case Laws Section 54 of the CGST Act,2017 only deals with claim of refund...

Section 54 of the CGST Act,2017 only deals with claim of refund under provisions of Act.

0
632

Comsol Energy (P.) Ltd. vs. State of Gujarat

High Court of Gujarat

R/Special Civil Application No. 11905 of 2020

Category: Refund – IGST paid under Reverse Charge on Ocean Freight

Date of Judgment: 21st December 2020

Relevant Sections: Article 226 of the Constitution of India, Section 54 of the CGST Act, Section 17 of the Limitation Act, Article 265 of the Constitution

 

Facts of the Case

[Para 2] The petitioner, Comsol Energy (P.) Ltd., filed refund claims for IGST paid under reverse charge on ocean freight for February and March 2018, pursuant to the judgment in their own case linked with Mohit Minerals (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India, where such levy was declared unconstitutional.
[Para 3] The department rejected the refund claims by issuing RFD-03 deficiency memos citing delay and absence of a specific refund category under Section 54 of the CGST Act.
[Para 6] The petitioner argued that IGST collected was without authority of law and hence refundable, invoking State of M.P. v. Bhailal Bhai (AIR 1964 SC 1006).
[Para 7] The petitioner contended that Section 54 CGST is inapplicable as it governs refunds of valid taxes, whereas their payment was made under mistake of law, and hence Section 17 of the Limitation Act applies.

Questions in Consideration

[Para 1, 4]

  1. Whether refund of IGST paid under RCM on ocean freight—later declared unconstitutional—is barred under Section 54 of the CGST Act due to limitation or categorization issues.
  2. Whether Limitation Act provisions override Section 54 for claims involving tax paid under a mistake of law.

Observations of the Court

[Para 5] The levy of IGST on ocean freight via Notification No. 8/2017 and Entry 10 of Notification No. 10/2017 was held ultra vires and unconstitutional in petitioner’s earlier case.
[Paras 6–10] The Court reaffirmed that tax collected without authority of law violates Article 265 of the Constitution and is refundable under writ jurisdiction. Several precedents, including Binani Cement Ltd., Joshi Technologies, and 3E Infotech Ltd., were cited to support that the Limitation Act, not GST law, applies in such cases.
[Para 11–12] The Court referred to similar rulings like Gokul Agro Resources Ltd. and Bharat Oman Refineries Ltd., where refunds were directed irrespective of Section 54 constraints due to invalidated levies.

Judgment of the Court

[Para 13] The Court quashed the deficiency memos (RFD-03 dated 17-7-2020).
[Para 14] The Respondents were directed to process the refund claim of ₹93.54 lakhs for February and March 2018, along with simple interest at 6% p.a.
[Para 15] The refund was to be granted by 17th August 2021.
[Para 16] Writ petition allowed and disposed of.

Between Fine Lines

  • Refund claims for unconstitutional levies (like IGST on ocean freight) are not barred by Section 54 of CGST Act.
  • Such levies are not “tax” under law, so general limitation under Section 17 of the Limitation Act applies.
  • The taxpayer can seek refund under Article 226 if payment was made by mistake of law.
  • No separate refund category or limitation under GST law can obstruct such claims.
  • Refund must be granted with interest if tax was collected without statutory backing.

Summary of Referred Cases

S. No. Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
1 Mohit Minerals (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India [2020] 113 taxmann.com 436/78 GST 579 Declared IGST levy on ocean freight via RCM as unconstitutional Notifications struck down
2 State of M.P. v. Bhailal Bhai AIR 1964 SC 1006 Payment of tax under mistake of law is refundable under writ jurisdiction Refund ordered
3 Binani Cement Ltd. v. Union of India 2013 (288) ELT 193 Duty collected without authority of law not governed by limitation under taxing statutes Refund allowed under Limitation Act
4 Joshi Technologies v. Union of India [2016] 71 taxmann.com 131 (Guj.) Refund claim under mistake of law not governed by Section 11B of Central Excise Act General limitation applies
5 3E Infotech Ltd. v. CESTAT 2018 (18) GSTL 410 (Mad.) Refund not barred by Section 11B if paid under mistake of law Refund allowed
6 Gokul Agro Resources Ltd. v. Union of India [2020] 116 taxmann.com 1/80 GST 169 Technicalities should not bar refund post invalidation of levy Refund ordered
7 Bharat Oman Refineries Ltd. v. Union of India [2020] 120 taxmann.com 301 IGST refund allowed on unconstitutional ocean freight levy Refund directed

 

Takeaway

“Mistaken Tax, Rightful Refund – Ocean Freight IGST Overturned”

LEAVE A REPLY