Home Case Laws Seized currency ordered to be released as the Court held that the...

Seized currency ordered to be released as the Court held that the issue was squarely covered by its earlier precedent in Deepak Khandelwal, thereby binding the Department to return the money within ten days.

0
217

Case Summary: Bhagwan Gupta & Ors. v. Commissioner of CGST, Delhi West & Ors., High Court of Delhi, W.P.(C) 13715/2023 (Order dated 10.11.2023)


Facts (with Para References)

The petitioners invoked writ jurisdiction seeking mandamus directing the CGST authorities to release ₹58,00,000 in Indian currency seized during a search operation at the residence of Petitioner No. 1 on 29.07.2021 under Section 67 of the CGST Act (Para 2). The petition also sought costs and consequential reliefs (Para 1). It was not disputed that the seizure was a result of departmental search proceedings under alleged GST violations.


Questions / Issues Before the Court (with Para References)

  1. Whether the Department could continue to retain cash seized under Section 67 when the factual matrix is identical to the Delhi High Court’s prior ruling in Deepak Khandelwal v. Commissioner of CGST, Delhi West? (Para 3)

  2. Whether the petitioners are entitled to immediate release of the seized currency? (Paras 1–2)


Court’s Observations (with Para References)

The Bench noted that concededly the controversy was squarely covered by the earlier Division Bench judgment in Deepak Khandelwal (Para 3). The respondent’s counsel made a categorical statement that the seized currency would be released within ten days (Para 4).

The Court bound the Department to this undertaking and clarified that such release would not obstruct statutory action for any violation of the GST law (Para 6).

The Court thereby adopted a pragmatic, precedent-consistent approach, avoiding re-litigation of settled principles.


Judgment / Verdict (Flowing Narrative with Para References)

The Court disposed of the writ petition by directing the CGST authorities to release the ₹58 lakh seized during the Section 67 search, strictly adhering to the Department’s commitment to effect release within ten days of the order (Para 4).

It further clarified that the release of the funds does not bar the Department from proceeding with appropriate statutory actions, if warranted, under the CGST Act (Para 6).

Thus, the relief was granted entirely on the strength of precedent parity, reaffirming judicial consistency in matters concerning seizure and retention of cash during GST search operations. (Paras 3–5)


Summary of Cases Referred (Tabular Form)

Case Referred Court Ratio / Verdict Relevance to Present Case
Deepak Khandelwal, Proprietor M/s Shri Shyam Metal v. Commissioner of CGST, Delhi West & Anr., 2023: DHC:5823-DB Delhi High Court Court held that continued retention of seized cash without lawful basis is impermissible; directed immediate release. Present case follows this binding precedent; issue considered fully covered by earlier judgment.

Between Fine Lines (Practical Takeaways for Trade/Industry)

The ruling reinforces that cash seized during GST searches cannot be retained indefinitely unless the Department demonstrates a clear statutory basis. Businesses facing similar seizures can rely on the Deepak Khandelwal line of cases to secure release of funds. However, release of money does not preclude continued investigation or prosecution under the CGST Act.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY