Home Case Laws Show-cause notice under Section 73 quashed as proceedings for transitional CENVAT credit...

Show-cause notice under Section 73 quashed as proceedings for transitional CENVAT credit could only be initiated under erstwhile laws, not CGST Ac

0
366

Case Summary

Case Title: Kunjal Synergies Private Limited & Anr. v. The Assistant Commissioner of CGST & CX, Park Street Division & Ors.
Court: High Court of Calcutta (Civil Appellate Jurisdiction – Appellate Side)
Petition No.: M.A.T. 2333 of 2023 with IA No. CAN 1 of 2023
Date of Judgment: 11.03.2025
Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit (Transitional Credit – TRAN 1)
Relevant Sections: Sections 73, 140, and 174 of the CGST Act, 2017; CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004

Facts (Para 1–7)

The appellants, engaged in trading and import of chemicals under CTH 2909, migrated to GST with effect from 1 July 2017 and filed TRAN-1 to carry forward closing balance of CENVAT credit of ₹41.55 lakh. The department initiated verification in 2018, repeatedly calling for documents, but did not adjudicate or issue a demand until 2023. Despite appellants’ replies, a show-cause notice under Section 73 of the CGST Act was issued in September 2023, alleging irregular transitional credit. The appellants argued that after years of departmental verification and acceptance of eligibility, a delayed SCN under CGST lacked jurisdiction.


Questions of Law (Para 8–9)

Whether the show-cause notice issued under Section 73 of the CGST Act questioning transitional CENVAT credit was within jurisdiction, considering that such disputes pertain to the erstwhile Central Excise and Service Tax laws.


Observations (Para 10–17)

The Court held that writ petitions are maintainable against SCNs when jurisdiction is in question, notwithstanding alternate remedies. Referring to Usha Martin Ltd. v. Addl. Commissioner, CGST & Excise, Jamshedpur and Steel Authority of India Ltd. v. State of Jharkhand, the Bench reiterated that proceedings for inadmissible transitional credit cannot be pursued under the CGST Act, as it would result in parallel jurisdiction and legal uncertainty. Instead, such disputes must be dealt with under the repealed but saved provisions of the Finance Act, 1994 and CENVAT Credit Rules.


Judgment (Para 18–19)

The Division Bench quashed the show-cause notice dated 18 September 2023 as being without jurisdiction. The Single Bench’s order was set aside, and the writ petition was allowed. However, liberty was granted to the department to initiate proceedings under the erstwhile laws, strictly “in accordance with law.”


Table of Cases Referred

Case Citation Verdict
Usha Martin Ltd. v. Addl. Commissioner, CGST & Excise [2024] 124 GSTR 396 (Jharkhand HC) SCN under CGST Act for transitional credit quashed; liberty to proceed under erstwhile laws.
Steel Authority of India Ltd. v. State of Jharkhand [TS-49-HC (JHAR)-2025-GST] Followed Usha Martin; adjudication order quashed; liberty preserved for action under old law.

Between Fine Lines

This judgment provides strong relief to taxpayers facing belated SCNs on transitional credit under GST. The Court clarified that transitional credit disputes must be adjudicated under pre-GST laws, not the CGST Act, preventing duplication of proceedings and jurisdictional overreach. For businesses, this ensures certainty in carrying forward CENVAT credit and protects against arbitrary demands years after transition.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY