Home Case Laws Show Cause Notice under Section 74 Stayed in Absence of Prima Facie...

Show Cause Notice under Section 74 Stayed in Absence of Prima Facie Evidence

0
601

Case Title: M/s Bhagya Kalita vs Union of India & Ors
Court: Gauhati High Court
Petition No.: WP(C)/6154/2024
Category: Invocation of Section 74 – Allegation of Suppression / Fraud
Date of Judgement/Order: 25.11.2024
Relevant Section: Section 74(1) of the CGST Act, 2017
Relief: Stay on SCN Proceedings


Facts of the Case (¶2–¶6)

  • M/s Bhagya Kalita, a proprietorship, challenged a show cause notice (SCN) dated 03.08.2024 issued under Section 74(1) of CGST Act, alleging wilful suppression/misstatement (¶2).

  • Petitioner contended that tax paid was duly acknowledged in the GST portal, and there is no prima facie material indicating fraud or suppression (¶4–¶5).

  • Petitioner relied on CBIC Circular dated 13.12.2023 stating that Section 74(1) can only be invoked in case of fraud, suppression, or wilful misstatement—not mere short payment of tax (¶6–¶7).


Question(s) in Consideration (¶3, ¶5, ¶8)

  • Whether Section 74(1) of the CGST Act can be invoked in absence of prima facie evidence of wilful suppression or fraud?

  • Whether issuance of SCN contrary to binding departmental circular and Supreme Court law can be sustained?


Observations of Court (¶9–¶17)

  • The Court acknowledged that the departmental circular and settled law require a threshold of wilful suppression/fraud to invoke Section 74(1) (¶6–¶9).

  • Petitioner relied on Calcutta Discount Co. Ltd. v. ITO [(1961) AIR 372] to argue that constitutional courts may intervene even when alternative statutory remedy exists if jurisdiction is wrongly assumed (¶10).

  • The Court accepted prima facie that initiation of SCN appears contrary to circular and law (¶15).

  • Issued notice returnable in 2 weeks; granted interim stay on proceedings pursuant to SCN dated 03.08.2024 (¶17).


Judgement of the Court (¶17–¶20)

  • Further proceedings pursuant to SCN dated 03.08.2024 are stayed until next hearing.

  • Matter to be listed on 09.12.2024 for further consideration.


Between Fine Lines:

  1. Section 74(1) cannot be used arbitrarily for any tax shortfall; there must be proof of suppression/fraud.

  2. Departmental officers must follow CBIC Circulars mandating limited use of Section 74.

  3. Jurisdictional defect in SCN allows constitutional court to entertain writ despite statutory remedies.

  4. Interim relief granted due to prima facie absence of grounds for invoking Section 74.

  5. The case upholds taxpayer protection from coercive proceedings without due cause.


Summary of Referred Cases:

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
Calcutta Discount Co. Ltd. v. ITO AIR 1961 SC 372 Supreme Court held writ jurisdiction valid when SCN is issued without jurisdiction or contrary to law Supports writ maintainability

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY