Case Details:
Case Title: Imarti Lakdi Vyapari Sansthan, Jodhpur v. State of Rajasthan
Court: Rajasthan High Court
Petition Number: D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 1451 of 2018
Date of Judgment: 29 October 2018
Relevant Section: Section 17 of the Rajasthan Agriculture Produce Marketing Act, 1961
Category of Dispute: Levy of Market Fee/Cess – Whether timber qualifies as agricultural produce; whether post-GST, such cess can continue
Relevant CGST/IGST Provisions: Section 174 of CGST Act, 2017 and RGST Act, 2017 – repeal and savings clause
Facts of the Case
- The petitioner is a registered society whose members are engaged in the trade of timber (Imarti Lakdi) and operate from outside the Mandi yard. They challenged the levy of Mandi cess under the Rajasthan Agriculture Produce Marketing Act, 1961, arguing that they do not use Mandi servicesImartiLakdiVyapariSanst…(Para 1–2).
- It was contended that timber is not an agricultural produce and hence not liable to Mandi fee. Further, with the introduction of GST, all cesses including Mandi cess should have been subsumed (Para 3–4).
- The society argued that the levy is arbitrary, violates Article 14 (equality) and Article 19(1)(g) (freedom to trade) of the Constitution of India (Para 4).
Questions in Consideration
- Whether timber is covered under “agricultural produce” under the Act of 1961, and thereby exigible to market fee? (Para 9)
- Whether the levy under the 1961 Act is a “cess” that should have been subsumed under GST? (Para 6, 11–14)
- Whether the levy violates fundamental rights under Article 14 and Article 19(1)(g)? (Para 4)
Observations of the Court
- The levy under Section 17 is a statutory “fee,” not a “cess,” and is authorized under Entry 66, List II, Seventh Schedule (Para 6–7).
- Market fee is chargeable irrespective of the location of trade within the notified market area, and services are deemed to be rendered throughout the notified area (Para 8).
- Timber is specifically mentioned in the Schedule to the Act, thus constituting agricultural produce for the purpose of the levy (Para 9).
- The inclusion of timber in the Schedule is valid and constitutionally permissible (Para 10).
- GST does not affect the validity of the market fee since it is not included in the repeal clauses of Section 174 of CGST or RGST Acts, and is imposed under a separate statute (Para 13–14).
Judgment of the Court
The writ petition was dismissed. The Court held that market fee on timber under the Rajasthan Agriculture Produce Marketing Act, 1961 is valid and unaffected by GST (Para 15).
Between Fine Lines
- Market fee is a regulatory fee, not a tax or cess.
- Timber is expressly listed as agricultural produce under the relevant state legislation.
- GST subsumed only specified levies; Mandi fee under state agriculture marketing laws is not among them.
- Location of business premises outside the Mandi yard does not exempt traders from market fee liability.
- Fundamental rights claims were dismissed due to statutory validity and regulatory purpose.
- Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| AIR 1983 SC 1246 | – | Market fee valid even outside market yard; services extend to entire notified area | In favour of State |
| ILR [1976] AP 878 | – | Rejected argument that market committee functions only in market yard | In favour of State |
| 1984 WLN 402 | – | Timber is validly included as agricultural produce under the Act | In favour of State |




