Home Case Laws Stay on GST demand granted as High Court applied reduced pre-deposit requirement...

Stay on GST demand granted as High Court applied reduced pre-deposit requirement in line with 2024 notifications

0
299

Case Title: Dillip Kumar Martha v. Additional CT & GST Officer, Nayagarh and Others
Court: High Court of Orissa at Cuttack
Petition No.: W.P.(C) No. 29986 of 2024
Date of Judgment: 07 January 2025
Category: Stay of GST demand pending appeal before unconstituted Tribunal
Relevant Section: Section 112(8) and Section 107(6) of the CGST/OGST Act, 2017


Facts (Para 1–3):

The petitioner, Dillip Kumar Martha, challenged the first appellate order dated 21 October 2024 before the Orissa High Court. Since the GST Appellate Tribunal was not yet constituted, the petitioner sought interim relief against the recovery of tax dues. Earlier, by an order dated 16 February 2024 in M/s Maa Tarini Traders v. State of Odisha (WP(C) No. 42015 of 2023), the High Court had directed assessees to deposit 10% of the disputed tax for appeal filing and an additional 20% for stay. However, a Central Notification dated 16 August 2024 reduced the additional deposit requirement from 20% to 10%, and the State of Odisha subsequently aligned through its Notification dated 29 October 2024.


Questions before the Court:

Whether the petitioner could avail the benefit of the reduced 10% deposit requirement for obtaining stay on recovery of demand under the first appellate order, in view of the revised State notification harmonizing with the Central GST notification.


Court’s Observations (Para 4–5):

The Bench noted that both Central and State notifications had now reduced the pre-deposit for stay of demand from 20% to 10%. Hence, the earlier directions in Maa Tarini Traders were to be read with this modification. The Court found merit in the petitioner’s submission that parity must be maintained between Central and State GST frameworks to avoid discriminatory treatment.


Judgment (Para 5–6):

Accepting the petitioner’s plea, the Court directed that the petitioner need only deposit 10% of the remaining disputed tax (beyond the initial 10% under Section 107(6)) for the impugned appellate order to remain stayed. The writ petition was accordingly disposed of, reaffirming the stay mechanism laid down in Maa Tarini Traders with the updated deposit rate.


Cases Referred:

Case Name Court & Petition No. Issue Verdict
M/s Maa Tarini Traders v. State of Odisha & Others Orissa HC – WP(C) No. 42015 of 2023 Stay of demand pending Tribunal constitution Deposit 10% + 20% of disputed tax; stay granted till Tribunal setup
Dillip Kumar Martha v. Additional CT & GST Officer Orissa HC – WP(C) No. 29986 of 2024 Applicability of reduced 10% deposit Stay granted with 10% of remaining disputed tax, in line with new notifications

Between Fine Lines:

This judgment ensures uniformity and relief for taxpayers awaiting Tribunal constitution by harmonizing State and Central deposit requirements. Businesses in Odisha can now secure stay of demand by depositing only 10% of the remaining disputed tax—halving the earlier financial burden and easing cash flow constraints during prolonged litigation.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.

LEAVE A REPLY