Home Case Laws Stay on GST recovery granted on 10% pre-deposit as Tribunal not constituted,...

Stay on GST recovery granted on 10% pre-deposit as Tribunal not constituted, ensuring taxpayer’s statutory right to appeal remains protected

0
387

Case Reference

M/s Jindal Steel v. State of Bihar & Ors.
Patna High Court
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 192 of 2025
Judgment Date: 08.01.2025
Category: Appeal / Pre-deposit / Tribunal Non-constitution
Relevant Sections: Section 107(6), Section 112(8) & (9), Bihar GST Act; Section 112 CGST Act, 2017

Facts (Paras 2–5)

The petitioner, M/s Jindal Steel, challenged the recovery proceedings arising from an assessment order under the Bihar GST Act. The petitioner intended to file an appeal before the GST Appellate Tribunal under Section 112. However, since the Tribunal had not been constituted, the petitioner was deprived of his statutory appellate remedy and consequential stay of recovery available under Section 112(8) & (9). Earlier, courts had permitted taxpayers to secure stay by depositing 20% of the disputed tax in terms of the ruling in SAJ Food Products Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Bihar. Subsequently, an amendment effective 01.11.2024 reduced the required pre-deposit to 10%.


Questions before the Court (Paras 2–6)

  • Whether the petitioner can be granted the statutory protection of stay under Section 112(9) when the Tribunal itself has not been constituted.

  • Whether the pre-deposit to secure stay should be 10% (as per amendment) or 20% (as earlier directed by courts pending Tribunal constitution).


Observations (Paras 5–7)

The Court noted that although the statutory appeal is unavailable due to non-constitution of the Tribunal, taxpayers cannot be deprived of the stay benefit, especially when the law now prescribes only 10% pre-deposit. Balancing equities, the Court emphasized that this relief cannot be open-ended. Once the Tribunal becomes functional, the petitioner must file an appeal within the prescribed time. Till then, recovery must remain stayed to safeguard the statutory right.


Judgment (Paras 7–8)

  1. On payment of 10% of the disputed tax (in addition to any deposit already made under Section 107(6)), the petitioner shall be granted stay of recovery under Section 112(9).

  2. Recovery proceedings and coercive steps shall remain stayed; any bank account attachment shall be released.

  3. The petitioner must file the statutory appeal before the Tribunal once it is constituted.

  4. If the petitioner does not file an appeal within the specified period after Tribunal constitution, the authorities may proceed as per law.

Thus, the writ petition was disposed of with liberty, directions, and protection against coercive recovery.


Table of Cases Referred

Case Court Citation Ratio / Outcome
SAJ Food Products Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Bihar & Ors. Patna High Court CWJC No. 15465 of 2022 Directed that in absence of Tribunal, taxpayers could deposit 20% of disputed tax to avail stay of recovery.

Between Fine Lines

For trade and industry, this judgment affirms that taxpayers cannot be penalized for the government’s failure to constitute GST Tribunals. By recognizing the amended law (10% pre-deposit), the Court has eased the financial burden while ensuring that the right to appeal is not rendered illusory. However, businesses must remain vigilant to file appeals promptly once the Tribunal is functional.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY