The Supreme Court, in Rashmirekha Tripathy and Another v. Branch Manager (Legal Claims), Sriram General Insurance Company Limited and Others, has laid down important principles governing the use of Income Tax Returns for determining the annual income of a deceased person or injured claimant under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
The judgment was delivered on 1 July 2026 by a Bench comprising Justice Sanjay Karol and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh in a civil appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 27220 of 2024. The decision is reported as 2026 INSC 661.
Background of the Case
The appellants were the legal representatives of Manoranjan Pandey, who died following a road accident on 29 May 2018. The deceased, aged about 39 years, was travelling from Behrampur to Bhubaneswar when his vehicle was struck by a truck being driven in a rash and negligent manner.
The claimants filed an application under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act seeking compensation on the basis that the deceased was engaged in the construction business and earned approximately ₹15 lakh annually.
The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Behrampur, assessed the deceased’s annual income at ₹15 lakh on the basis of the Income Tax Return for Assessment Year 2018–19 and awarded compensation of ₹2,27,00,064 with interest at 6% per annum.
On appeal by the insurer, the Orissa High Court considered the average income disclosed in two Income Tax Returns and reduced the annual income to ₹13,33,226. Consequently, the total compensation was reduced to ₹1,87,75,150.
The claimants challenged the reduction before the Supreme Court.
Issue Before the Supreme Court
The principal question before the Court was whether the annual income of a deceased person or claimant should be determined on the basis of the Income Tax Return for the immediately preceding year or by averaging the income shown in the returns for the previous two or three years.
The Court observed that there was no uniform approach across courts. In some cases, the latest Income Tax Return was considered, while in others, the average income disclosed over three years was adopted.
No Rigid Formula for Assessing Income
The Supreme Court held that there can be no inflexible or universal formula for computing the annual income of a deceased person or claimant.
Income Tax Returns are statutory documents and constitute an important reference point for assessing income. However, the figures disclosed in the returns cannot always be applied mechanically. The nature of employment, profession or business, the pattern of income and other surrounding financial circumstances must also be examined.
The Court reiterated that the object of compensation proceedings under the Motor Vehicles Act is to grant just and fair compensation. The assessment is not an exact mathematical exercise and must ultimately be guided by fairness and the particular facts of each case.
Separate Approach for Salaried and Self-Employed Persons
A significant feature of the judgment is the distinction drawn between salaried individuals and persons who are self-employed or carrying on business.
In the case of a salaried individual, the Income Tax Return for the immediately preceding year would ordinarily be sufficient to establish annual salary income. The Court reasoned that promotions and increments may significantly increase income, and such an increase may be reflected only in the most recent return.
Where a promotion or salary revision occurred shortly before the accident and was not reflected in an Income Tax Return, courts may consider the promotion letter, salary statements and other corroborative financial records.
In the case of a self-employed individual or a person carrying on business, the average income disclosed in the Income Tax Returns for up to the previous three years should ordinarily be taken as a reference point.
However, the average of the returns is not conclusive. Courts must also consider the nature of the business, its location and category, its growth pattern, the effect of the person’s death on the business, its future potential and whether initial losses were attributable to the capital-intensive nature of the enterprise.
Returns Filed After Death or Injury
The Supreme Court also addressed Income Tax Returns filed after the death or injury of the claimant.
The date on which the return was filed is a relevant consideration because income may, in some cases, be inflated after the accident or death. Nevertheless, a return filed subsequently cannot be rejected automatically.
Where such a return is supported by balance sheets, financial statements and other reliable business records, it may still be considered while determining income.
Application of the Principles to the Present Case
The deceased had filed Income Tax Returns showing income of ₹11,59,882 for Assessment Year 2017–18 and ₹15,06,571 for Assessment Year 2018–19.
The High Court took the arithmetic average of the two returns and assessed annual income at ₹13,33,226. The Supreme Court found that the High Court had not adequately considered the surrounding circumstances, particularly the fact that the deceased was running a construction business.
Having regard to the Income Tax Returns, the nature of the business and the requirement of awarding just and fair compensation, the Supreme Court fixed the deceased’s annual income at ₹14 lakh.
The Court recalculated the compensation by applying future prospects and awarding amounts under the conventional heads. The total compensation was fixed at ₹1,97,81,505, as against ₹1,87,75,150 awarded by the High Court.
The civil appeal was accordingly allowed, and the High Court’s judgment was modified. Interest on the enhanced amount was directed to be paid at the rate awarded by the Tribunal. The insurer was further directed to remit the amount directly into the claimants’ bank account within four weeks after receiving the necessary particulars.
Principles Emerging from the Judgment
The judgment establishes that Income Tax Returns are important but not invariably decisive evidence of income in motor accident compensation proceedings.
For salaried persons, the latest preceding return will ordinarily provide the appropriate basis. For self-employed persons and business owners, courts should generally refer to the average income disclosed during the previous three years, while also evaluating the commercial and financial circumstances of the business.
The decision discourages a purely mechanical averaging of Income Tax Returns and requires Motor Accident Claims Tribunals and appellate courts to adopt a realistic, fact-sensitive approach consistent with the statutory obligation to award just compensation.




