Home Case Laws Tax Collected through Reversal of Input Tax Credit during Search Proceedings during...

Tax Collected through Reversal of Input Tax Credit during Search Proceedings during midnight cannot be treated as voluntary payment of tax by assessee.

0
549

Case Title: Shree Ganesh Molasses Trading Co. v. Superintendent, Office of the Commissioner

Court Name: High Court of Gujarat

Petition Number: R/Special Civil Application No. 4026 of 2022

Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit

Date of Judgment: 18 January 2023

Relevant Sections: Sections 67, 73(5), 74(5), 79 of the CGST Act, 2017; Rule 142(2) of CGST Rules, 2017

Takeaway: “No Midnight Coercion – Voluntariness Is the Key to GST Recovery”

 

Facts of the Case

[Para 1-5] The petitioner, Shree Ganesh Molasses Trading Co., engaged in chemical trading, alleged coercive reversal of ITC worth ₹37,68,300 during a midnight search on 12.02.2022. The reversal and DRC-03 filing were done under threat by CGST officials, using login credentials of a partner’s son based in Mumbai.

[Para 4-7] Despite full cooperation, including providing all records and filing a retraction affidavit on 18.02.2022, the department did not refund the amount. The petitioner argued no adjudication or assessment had been made, hence coercive recovery violated legal procedures.

[Para 8-10] The respondent contended no coercion was used and the petitioner failed to produce documents during the search. The officers claimed authority under Section 67(1) of the CGST Act.

 

Questions in Consideration

[Para 7, 19]

  1. Whether reversal of ITC through DRC-03 under threat during midnight search violates the principles of natural justice and prescribed GST procedures?
  2. Whether such reversal is invalid without issuance of a show cause notice and adjudication?
  3. Whether the instructions laid down in Bhumi Associate and CBIC Instruction No. 01/2022-23 are binding?

 

Observations of the Court

[Para 15-20]

  • The High Court referenced Bhumi Associate v. Union of India and CBIC Instruction No. 01/2022-23, emphasizing that recovery during search should only be voluntary and post-search.
  • Audio transcript between the officer and son of the petitioner proved coercion.
  • The actions violated earlier Gujarat HC directions (SCA 3196/2021), reaffirmed by Delhi HC in Vallabh Textiles.
  • Filing of DRC-03 at 1 AM without legal advice or proper opportunity was held to be devoid of voluntariness.

 

Judgment of the Court

[Para 22]

  • The Court directed the revenue authorities to reverse the ITC of ₹37,68,300 with 6% interest.
  • The petition was allowed, terming the act as non-voluntary and violative of binding judicial guidelines.

 

Between Fine Lines (Simplified Outcome)

  • GST officers cannot force ITC reversal or tax payments during searches.
  • Voluntary payments must follow due process and time for legal advice.
  • Midnight filings of DRC-03 forms under pressure are invalid.
  • Courts uphold taxpayer rights against coercive recovery.
  • Refund with interest was ordered due to unlawful reversal of ITC.

 

Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict/Use in Judgment
Bhumi Associate v. Union of India [2021] 124 taxmann.com 429 / SCA No. 3196/2021 (Gujarat HC) Laid down guidelines banning recovery during search unless voluntary and post-search filing of DRC-03 Basis for directions violated in present case
Vallabh Textiles v. SIO [2022] 145 taxmann.com 596 / [2023] 95 GST 751 / [2022 (12) TMI 1038] (Delhi HC) Reaffirmed Bhumi Associate principles and invalidated coercive recovery without proper legal backing Strengthened petitioner’s claim of non-voluntary payment
Instruction No. 01/2022-23 CBIC, dated 25.05.2022 CBIC guideline based on Bhumi directing no coercive recovery during search; encouraged post-search DRC-03 filing Demonstrated that department’s conduct violated its own binding instructions

 

Download Judgement

LEAVE A REPLY