Case Title: Laxmi & Ors. v. Indore Smart City Development Ltd. & Ors.
Court: High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Indore Bench
Petition Nos.: WP No. 30072/2024, 30068/2024, 30077/2024, 30081/2024
Judgment Date: 18 December 2024
Category of Dispute: GST applicability on tender premium – Input Tax applicability and contract compliance
Relevant Sections: Article 226 of the Constitution of India; Section 9 and Section 15 of the CGST Act, 2017; relevant tender clauses and M.P. Municipal (Achal Sampatti Antaran) Rules, 2016
Facts (Para 2–8)
The Indore Smart City Development Ltd. floated a tender for the allotment of 11 shops at Gopal Mandir Amphitheatre Complex, Indore, under the M.P. Municipal (Achal Sampatti Antaran) Rules, 2016. The petitioners were successful bidders for certain shops and were issued allotment letters requiring deposit of 25% of the premium amount along with 18% GST within 21 days.
The petitioners objected, claiming GST should apply only on rent after possession, not on the one-time premium. They refused to pay the GST component and sought a hearing. Despite repeated notices and extensions, they neither deposited the 25% amount nor GST. The authority then cancelled their allotments and reissued the tender. The petitioners challenged the cancellation under Article 226, contending violation of natural justice and unjustified GST levy.
Questions Before the Court (Para 6–8)
-
Whether GST at 18% was justifiably demanded on the upfront premium amount for shop allotment?
-
Whether cancellation of tender without personal hearing violated principles of natural justice?
-
Whether parity could be claimed with other bidders who were granted time extensions?
Observations (Para 9–10)
The Court noted that Clause 20.02 of the tender conditions expressly required payment of 25% of the premium plus 18% GST within 21 days. The petitioners, having participated in the tender with full knowledge of the conditions, could not later dispute the GST component.
The Court observed that the respondents provided multiple opportunities and extended time for deposit, but the petitioners failed to comply. Unlike other bidders who deposited partial amounts, the petitioners made no payment at all, hence could not claim parity. The objections were deemed frivolous and an attempt to delay compliance, causing financial loss to the public authority.
Judgment (Para 11–13)
The Court held that:
-
The cancellation was lawful and justified as the petitioners violated the terms of the tender.
-
Adequate opportunity was provided before cancellation.
-
GST demand on the premium amount was part of the contract and binding.
Accordingly, all writ petitions were dismissed, and respondents were granted liberty to claim damages from the petitioners.
Summary of Cases Referred
| Case Name | Citation | Held / Principle |
|---|---|---|
| Laxmi & Ors. v. Indore Smart City Development Ltd. | WP No. 30072/2024 (MPHC, 2024) | GST on tender premium upheld; cancellation valid for non-compliance |
| Rajat v. Indore Smart City Development Ltd. | WP No. 30068/2024 (MPHC, 2024) | Same reasoning applied; no relief granted |
| Lokesh v. Indore Smart City Development Ltd. | WP No. 30077/2024 (MPHC, 2024) | Petition dismissed; parity with others denied |
| Rachna v. Indore Smart City Development Ltd. | WP No. 30081/2024 (MPHC, 2024) | Same order applicable; dismissal with liberty to recover damages |
Between Fine Lines
This decision reinforces that bidders in government tenders must adhere strictly to the terms and cannot later challenge contractual tax components like GST after accepting bid conditions. In commercial contracts, ignorance of tax applicability or refusal to comply cannot stall public projects. The takeaway for industry players is to factor GST obligations at the bid stage and ensure timely compliance to avoid cancellation and forfeiture risks.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




