Home Updates Gujarat High Court Issues Notice on GST Liability for Corporate Guarantees –...

Gujarat High Court Issues Notice on GST Liability for Corporate Guarantees – Torrent Investment Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India

0
187

The Gujarat High Court, in Torrent Investment Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors., considered an important challenge relating to the levy of GST on corporate guarantees provided by a holding company in favour of its subsidiaries without charging any consideration. The petition raises significant questions regarding the constitutional validity of Rule 28(2) of the CGST/GGST Rules, 2017 and the CBIC Circulars dated 27 October 2023 and 11 July 2024 prescribing valuation of such guarantees.

The petitioner sought declarations that the provision of a corporate guarantee without consideration should not constitute a taxable supply under the GST law and challenged the deemed valuation mechanism prescribing a value of 1% per annum for such guarantees. It was also argued that the impugned valuation provisions and circulars are contrary to Articles 14, 246A and 265 of the Constitution and inconsistent with Sections 7 and 9 of the GST Acts. During the hearing, however, the petitioner did not press its constitutional challenge to Section 7(1)(c) read with Schedule I at that stage.

The Court noted that similar issues concerning GST on corporate guarantees are already pending before the Delhi High Court and the Punjab & Haryana High Court. The petitioner further contended that since no fee or commission was charged from its subsidiary, the transaction should be treated on the same footing as personal guarantees discussed in the CBIC Circular dated 27 October 2023, where the taxable value may effectively be treated as nil in the absence of consideration.

Pending adjudication, the petitioner agreed to discharge GST under protest in accordance with Rule 28(2) from 1 August 2024. Taking note of the submissions, the Gujarat High Court issued notice in the matter and directed that although proceedings pursuant to the show cause notice may continue, no final order shall be passed by the tax authorities without the permission of the Court during the pendency of the petition.

Why This Judgment Matters

This order is significant for companies providing corporate guarantees to related entities without charging consideration. The challenge directly concerns the legality of Rule 28(2), the valuation mechanism introduced for corporate guarantees, and the CBIC circulars governing such transactions. The interim protection granted by the High Court also offers important guidance for taxpayers facing similar proceedings until the legal issues are finally decided.

Professionals including Chartered Accountants, Advocates, GST Practitioners, Corporate Tax Teams and businesses dealing with intra-group financing arrangements should closely monitor this litigation as its outcome could substantially impact the GST treatment of corporate guarantees across India.

LEAVE A REPLY