Home Case Laws Transitional credit denial quashed as GST new registration was held to be...

Transitional credit denial quashed as GST new registration was held to be compelled by CBEC helpdesk advice, not voluntary

0
182

Case Summary

Case Title: Javed Ahmed Khan v. Deputy Commissioner of Revenue, State Tax, Ballygunge and Ors.
Court: Calcutta High Court
Petition Number: MAT 2126 of 2024 with CAN/1/2024 and CAN/2/2024
Category of Dispute: Transitional Credit (TRAN-1)
Date of Judgment: 25 March 2025
Relevant Sections/Rules: Section 140 of the CGST Act, 2017; Rule 8 of the CGST Rules, 2017

Facts (Paras 1–3)

The appellant challenged the rejection of his transitional credit (TRAN-1) amounting to ₹35,59,064. The Department rejected the claim on 7 February 2023, holding that the appellant voluntarily applied for new registration under Rule 8 of the CGST Rules, 2017, instead of migrating from existing law on 1 July 2017. Since no GSTR-3B was filed for July 2017, the transitional credit was denied. The appellant argued that this was not a voluntary act but a consequence of technical glitches and subsequent advice from the CBEC helpdesk.

Emails exchanged on 27 June 2017 and 16 August 2017 demonstrated that the appellant faced a technical breach in obtaining the provisional ID for GST migration and was advised by the CBEC helpdesk to apply for a new registration on the GST common portal. The appellant acted on such instructions.


Questions Before the Court (Paras 2–3)

Whether the application for new registration was truly voluntary or a compelled measure based on departmental instructions, and if transitional credit could be denied on such technical grounds.


Observations (Paras 3–4)

The Court noted that the application for new registration was not voluntary but pursuant to the advice of the CBEC helpdesk. Therefore, the appellant could not be denied transitional credit merely because he did not migrate using the provisional ID. The rejection order failed to appreciate the peculiar facts and circumstances faced by the appellant during transition to GST.


Judgment (Paras 4–5)

The High Court allowed the appeal and writ petition, set aside the rejection order dated 7 February 2023, and remanded the matter to the Deputy Commissioner of Revenue, State Tax, Ballygunge. The authority was directed to reconsider the claim for transitional credit afresh, treating the new registration as compelled by departmental advice. The officer was instructed to provide a personal hearing and pass a fresh order within three weeks of receiving the court’s order.


Cases Referred (with verdicts)

Case Verdict
None explicitly cited in the judgment Court relied primarily on correspondence between assessee and CBEC helpdesk to establish lack of voluntariness.

Between Fine Lines

This judgment clarifies that transitional credit claims cannot be denied on hyper-technical grounds when taxpayers act on the advice of the CBEC helpdesk. For industry, it means that genuine technical glitches and departmental directions during GST migration cannot deprive businesses of substantive rights like input tax credit. Authorities must adopt a pragmatic approach and provide relief where compliance hurdles were not voluntary lapses.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY