Home Case Laws Transitional credit on capital goods in transit disallowed as GST law consciously...

Transitional credit on capital goods in transit disallowed as GST law consciously excludes such benefit, distinguishing them from inputs

0
352

Case Reference

M/s JMD Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
High Court of Judicature at Patna
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 15940 of 2023
Judgment dated: 30.01.2025
Relevant Provisions: Section 140(2) & 140(5), Section 73, Section 17 CGST Act, 2017; Rule 117 CGST Rules, 2017
Category: Input Tax Credit – Transitional Credit on Capital Goods in Transit

Facts (Paras 2–5)

The petitioner, a public limited company engaged in manufacturing MS Bars, had purchased capital goods in June 2017 under 11 excise invoices with CENVAT duty of ₹8,62,566. These goods, though invoiced in June 2017, were received only in July 2017, i.e., post-GST implementation. The petitioner filed TRAN-1 on 20.09.2017 claiming credit. However, the Superintendent (Respondent No. 4) disallowed credit citing Section 140(2) & (5) CGST Act, holding that transitional ITC on capital goods received after 01.07.2017 was not permissible.


Dispute / Questions (Paras 6–8)

Whether CENVAT duty paid on capital goods in transit before GST but received after 01.07.2017 is eligible for transitional credit under Section 140 of the CGST Act, 2017?


Observations of the Court (Paras 14–21)

  • The Court analyzed the history of CENVAT Credit Rules, 1944, 2004 and 2017 and noted that earlier statutes allowed credit on both inputs and capital goods.

  • Under GST, while Section 16 permits ITC on both inputs and capital goods, Section 140(5) specifically restricts transitional credit only to inputs and input services, consciously excluding capital goods.

  • The Gujarat High Court ruling in RSPL Ltd. v. Union of India, 2018 (19) GSTL 430 (Guj.) was relied upon, where it was held that such exclusion is not arbitrary, as capital goods and inputs form distinct classes. The SLP against that decision was dismissed by the Supreme Court (SLP (Civil) Diary No. 8350/2019, order dated 05.04.2019).

  • The Court agreed that the legislative intent was to avoid indefinite keeping of transitional claims open for capital goods, which are slow-moving and often involve longer delivery/installation timelines.


Judgment / Verdict (Paras 22–23)

  • The Court upheld both the Order-in-Original (27.07.2022) and Order-in-Appeal (25.05.2023) rejecting the credit.

  • Held that CENVAT credit of ₹8,62,566 on capital goods received after 01.07.2017 was rightly disallowed, as Section 140(5) does not cover such cases.

  • Writ petition dismissed as devoid of merit.


Table of Cases Referred

Case Court Citation Verdict
RSPL Ltd. v. Union of India Gujarat High Court 2018 (19) GSTL 430 (Guj.) Held transitional ITC under Section 140(5) limited to inputs and input services; capital goods excluded.
SLP (Civil) Diary No. 8350/2019 – RSPL Ltd. Supreme Court of India Order dated 05.04.2019 SLP dismissed, thereby upholding Gujarat HC ruling.

Between Fine Lines (Trade takeaway)

Businesses cannot claim transitional ITC on capital goods in transit received after 01.07.2017, even if duty was paid under excise earlier. Inputs and capital goods are legislatively distinct for transitional purposes, and the judiciary has consistently upheld this classification. Industry must carefully assess transitional claims to avoid litigation and interest/penalty exposure.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY